由於IOS-XR上的路由策略不是最優而導致BGP收斂緩慢的故障排除
下載選項
已更新: 2022 年 1 月 31 日
文件 ID:217634
無偏見用語
本產品的文件集力求使用無偏見用語。針對本文件集的目的，無偏見係定義為未根據年齡、身心障礙、性別、種族身分、民族身分、性別傾向、社會經濟地位及交織性表示歧視的用語。由於本產品軟體使用者介面中硬式編碼的語言、根據 RFP 文件使用的語言，或引用第三方產品的語言，因此本文件中可能會出現例外狀況。深入瞭解思科如何使用包容性用語。
關於此翻譯
思科已使用電腦和人工技術翻譯本文件，讓全世界的使用者能夠以自己的語言理解支援內容。請注意，即使是最佳機器翻譯，也不如專業譯者翻譯的內容準確。Cisco Systems, Inc. 對這些翻譯的準確度概不負責，並建議一律查看原始英文文件（提供連結）。
簡介
本文描述如何診斷Cisco IOS® XR路由器上由於非最佳路由策略而發生的緩慢BGP收斂問題。
背景
BGP收斂時間由許多因素組成。其中之一是通過配置的路由策略處理入口或出口BGP更新的時間。可以通過多種方式編寫路由策略來執行特定任務。最佳方式有助於改進BGP收斂、最小化潛在流量丟棄並避免臨時路由環路。Cisco IOS® XR包括一個分析工具，用於測量特定路由策略花費的時間，以便估計其處理時間。
問題
BGP收斂速度慢有時是採用非最佳方式寫入路由策略的結果。
解決方案
有一個用於路由策略的策略分析工具，它可以在不影響效能的情況下使用，以測量路由策略在某個特定連線點上每個語句所花費的時間。您可以檢查路由策略在此特定連線點的運行時間。預設情況下，僅對聚合路由策略狀態啟用分析。
router bgp 65000
neighbor 10.0.54.6
remote-as 65000
update-source Loopback0
address-family ipv4 unicast
route-policy INGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY in
!
neighbor 10.0.54.11
remote-as 65001
ebgp-multihop 255
update-source Loopback0
address-family ipv4 unicast
route-policy EGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY out
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#show pcl protocol bgp speaker-0 neighbor-in-dflt default-IPv4-Uni-10.0.54.6 policy profile
Policy profiling data
Policy : INGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
Pass : 1440233
Drop : 0
# of executions : 1440233
Total execution time : 57095msec <===========
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#show bgp ipv4 unicast neighbors 10.0.54.11 | i Update group
Update group: 0.3 Filter-group: 0.5 No Refresh request being processed
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#show pcl protocol bgp speaker-0 neighbor-out-dflt default-IPv4-Uni-UpdGrp-0.3-Out policy profile
Policy profiling data
Policy : EGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
Pass : 726751
Drop : 0
# of executions : 726751
Total execution time : 108099msec <===========
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#
您可以看到處理INGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY和EGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY所花費的累計時間量。
該分析可應用於任何連線點的入口或出口路由策略。
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#show pcl protocol bgp speaker-0 ?
debug-policy Attachpoint name
permnet Attachpoint name
import Attachpoint name
export Attachpoint name
interafi-import Attachpoint name
source-rt Attachpoint name
interafi-export Attachpoint name
retain-rt Attachpoint name
addpath Attachpoint name
neighbor-in-dflt Attachpoint name
neighbor-in-vrf Attachpoint name
neighbor-out-dflt Attachpoint name
neighbor-out-vrf Attachpoint name
orf-dflt Attachpoint name
orf-vrf Attachpoint name
dampening-dflt Attachpoint name
dampening-vrf Attachpoint name
default-originate-dflt Attachpoint name
default-originate-vrf Attachpoint name
clear-policy Attachpoint name
show-policy-node0_RSP1_CPU0 Attachpoint name
aggregation-dflt Attachpoint name
aggregation-vrf Attachpoint name
nexthop Attachpoint name
allocate-label Attachpoint name
label-mode Attachpoint name
l2vpn-import Attachpoint name
l2vpn-export Attachpoint name
redistribution-dflt Attachpoint name
redistribution-vrf Attachpoint name
rib-install-dflt Attachpoint name
rib-install-vrf Attachpoint name
network-dflt Attachpoint name
network-vrf Attachpoint name
redistribution-dflt Attachpoint name
redistribution-vrf Attachpoint name
rib-install-dflt Attachpoint name
rib-install-vrf Attachpoint name
network-dflt Attachpoint name
network-vrf Attachpoint name
l2vpn-export-mp2mp Attachpoint name
l2vpn-export-vfi Attachpoint name
l2vpn-export-evi Attachpoint name
l2vpn-export-mspw Attachpoint name
l2vpn-export-instance Attachpoint name
WORD Attachpoint name
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#
您可以根據需要清除統計資訊。
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#clear pcl protocol bgp speaker-0 neighbor-in-dflt default-IPv4-Uni-10.0.54.6 policy profile
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#clear pcl protocol bgp speaker-0 neighbor-out-dflt default-IPv4-Uni-UpdGrp-0.3-Out policy profile
如果啟用debug pcl profile detail，則會獲取每個路由策略條目的詳細統計資訊。
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#debug pcl profile detail
這些輸出是在收到完整的Internet BGP表標度並進一步傳播後收集的。
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#show pcl protocol bgp speaker-0 neighbor-in-dflt default-IPv4-Uni-10.0.54.6 policy profile
Policy profiling data
Policy : INGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
Pass : 720100
Drop : 0
# of executions : 720100
Total execution time : 222788msec <============== about 3.7 minutes to process ingress updates
Node Id Num visited Exec time Policy engine operation
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PXL_0_1 720100 221796msec if as-path aspath-match ... then <==============
PXL_0_3 3525 3msec set local-preference 150
3525 0msec
PXL_0_2 716575 225msec set local-preference 50
716575 82msec
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#show pcl protocol bgp speaker-0 neighbor-out-dflt default-IPv4-Uni-UpdGrp-0.3-Out policy profile
Policy profiling data
Policy : EGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
Pass : 720105
Drop : 0
# of executions : 720105
Total execution time : 221975msec <============== about 3.7 minutes to process egress updates
Node Id Num visited Exec time Policy engine operation
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PXL_0_1 720105 3005msec if as-path aspath-match ... then
PXL_0_5 0 0msec set med 70
0 0msec
PXL_0_2 720105 218008msec if as-path aspath-match ... then <==============
PXL_0_3 25 0msec set med 80
25 0msec
PXL_0_4 720080 145msec set med 90
720080 76msec
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#您可以看到，INGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY的線路PXL_0_1和EGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY的線路PXL_0_2尤其耗時，並且會降低收斂速度。
如果將它們與路由策略相關聯，您會發現INGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY中的AS-PATH-SET-11和EGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY中的AS-PATH-SET-22都會導致該問題。每個AS路徑集由100個正規表示式行組成，這是編寫策略非常低效的方法，因為它不會利用任何可能的最佳化或正規表示式的強大功能。
route-policy INGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
if as-path in AS-PATH-SET-11 then
set local-preference 150
else
set local-preference 50
endif
end-policy
route-policy EGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
if as-path in AS-PATH-SET-21 then
set med 70
elseif as-path in AS-PATH-SET-22 then
set med 80
else
set med 90
endif
end-policy
as-path-set AS-PATH-SET-11
ios-regex '^65101 65201_',
ios-regex '^65102 65202_',
ios-regex '^65103 65203_',
ios-regex '^65104 65204_',
ios-regex '^65105 65205_',
--- removed 90 similar lines ---
ios-regex '^65195 65295_',
ios-regex '^65196 65296_',
ios-regex '^65197 65297_',
ios-regex '^65198 65298_',
ios-regex '^65199 65299_'
end-set
as-path-set AS-PATH-SET-21
ios-regex '^$'
end-set
as-path-set AS-PATH-SET-22
ios-regex '^65169(_65169)*$',
ios-regex '^65392(_65392)*$',
ios-regex '^65133(_65133)*$',
ios-regex '^65231(_65231)*$',
ios-regex '^65161(_65161)*$',
--- removed 90 similar lines ---
ios-regex '^65281(_65281)*$',
ios-regex '^65336(_65336)*$',
ios-regex '^65238(_65238)*$',
ios-regex '^65381(_65381)*$',
ios-regex '^65103(_65103)*$'
end-set
為了提高策略效能，可以使用本機as-path match操作而不是正規表示式來評估AS路徑集的配置。或者，您也可以在路由策略內以摺疊方式使用正規表示式，從而減少使用的正規表示式行的數量。
下表列出路由策略語言(RPL)提供的AS路徑匹配條件。 本機匹配函式使用二進位制匹配演算法，與正規表示式匹配引擎相比，該演算法具有更好的效能。大多數常見的ios-regex匹配場景都可以與其一起編寫（或其組合）。
|
指令 |
說明 |
|
is-local |
確定路由器（或此自治系統或聯盟中的另一台路由器）是否發起路由 |
|
長度 |
根據AS路徑的長度執行條件檢查 |
|
neighbor-is |
根據一個或多個整數值或引數的序列，測試AS路徑頭部的自治系統編號。 |
|
originates-from |
從開始根據AS序列測試AS路徑包含發起路由的AS編號。 |
|
直通 |
測試以瞭解指定的整數或引數是否出現在AS路徑中的任何位置，或者整數和引數的序列是否出現。 |
|
unique-length |
根據AS路徑的長度執行特定檢查，忽略重複項 |
驗證
這些策略是藉助本地匹配條件重新編排的路由策略。這導致處理時間顯著減少。
route-policy INGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
if as-path in AS-PATH-SET-11 then
set local-preference 150
else
set local-preference 50
endif
end-policy
route-policy EGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
if as-path is-local then
set med 70
elseif as-path in AS-PATH-SET-22 and as-path unique-length is 1 then
set med 80
else
set med 90
endif
end-policy
as-path-set AS-PATH-SET-11
neighbor-is '65101 65201',
neighbor-is '65102 65202',
neighbor-is '65103 65203',
neighbor-is '65104 65204',
neighbor-is '65105 65205',
--- removed 90 similar lines ---
neighbor-is '65195 65295',
neighbor-is '65196 65296',
neighbor-is '65197 65297',
neighbor-is '65198 65298',
neighbor-is '65199 65299'
end-set
as-path-set AS-PATH-SET-22
originates-from '65169',
originates-from '65392',
originates-from '65133',
originates-from '65231',
originates-from '65161',
--- removed 90 similar lines ---
originates-from '65281',
originates-from '65336',
originates-from '65238',
originates-from '65381',
originates-from '65103'
end-set
這些輸出是在收到完整的Internet BGP表擴展後收集並進一步傳播的。
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#show pcl protocol bgp speaker-0 neighbor-in-dflt default-IPv4-Uni-10.0.54.6 policy profile
Policy profiling data
Policy : INGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
Pass : 720100
Drop : 0
# of executions : 720100
Total execution time : 9612msec <============== about 10 seconds to process ingress updates
Node Id Num visited Exec time Policy engine operation
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PXL_0_1 720100 8540msec if as-path aspath-match ... then
PXL_0_3 7128 2msec set local-preference 150
7128 1msec
PXL_0_2 712972 276msec set local-preference 50
712972 80msec
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#show pcl protocol bgp speaker-0 neighbor-out-dflt default-IPv4-Uni-UpdGrp-0.3-Out policy profile
Policy profiling data
Policy : EGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
Pass : 720126
Drop : 0
# of executions : 720126
Total execution time : 12399msec <============== about 12 seconds to process egress updates
Node Id Num visited Exec time Policy engine operation
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PXL_0_1 720126 190msec if as-path is-local then
PXL_0_7 0 0msec set med 70
0 0msec
PXL_0_2 720126 11190msec if as-path aspath-match ... then
PXL_0_4 262734 65msec if as-path unique-length is 1 then
PXL_0_5 25 0msec set med 80
25 0msec
PXL_0_6 720101 164msec set med 90
720101 57msec
GOTO : PXL_0_6
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#或者，可以摺疊ios-regex行。這也有助於提高效能。
route-policy INGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
if as-path in (ios-regex '^(65101_65201|65102_65202|65103_65203|65104_65204|65105_65205|65106_65206|65107_65207|65108_65208|65109_65209|65110_65210)') then
set local-preference 150
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^(65111_65211|65112_65212|65113_65213|65114_65214|65115_65215|65116_65216|65117_65217|65118_65218|65119_65219|65120_65220)') then
set local-preference 150
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^(65121_65221|65122_65222|65123_65223|65124_65224|65125_65225|65126_65226|65127_65227|65128_65228|65129_65229|65130_65230)') then
set local-preference 150
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^(65131_65231|65132_65232|65133_65233|65134_65234|65135_65235|65136_65236|65137_65237|65138_65238|65139_65239|65140_65240)') then
set local-preference 150
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^(65141_65241|65142_65242|65143_65243|65144_65244|65145_65245|65146_65246|65147_65247|65148_65248|65149_65249|65150_65250)') then
set local-preference 150
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^(65151_65251|65152_65252|65153_65253|65154_65254|65155_65255|65156_65256|65157_65257|65158_65258|65159_65259|65160_65260)') then
set local-preference 150
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^(65161_65261|65162_65262|65163_65263|65164_65264|65165_65265|65166_65266|65167_65267|65168_65268|65169_65269|65170_65270)') then
set local-preference 150
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^(65171_65271|65172_65272|65173_65273|65174_65274|65175_65275|65176_65276|65177_65277|65178_65278|65179_65279|65180_65280)') then
set local-preference 150
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^(65181_65281|65182_65282|65183_65283|65184_65284|65185_65285|65186_65286|65187_65287|65188_65288|65189_65289|65190_65290)') then
set local-preference 150
else
set local-preference 50
endif
end-policy
route-policy EGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
if as-path in (ios-regex '^$') then
set med 70
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65169(_65169)*$|^65392(_65392)*$|^65133(_65133)*$|^65231(_65231)*$|^65161(_65161)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65354(_65354)*$|^65331(_65331)*$|^65342(_65342)*$|^65295(_65295)*$|^65208(_65208)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65149(_65149)*$|^65350(_65350)*$|^65115(_65115)*$|^65300(_65300)*$|^65322(_65322)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65102(_65102)*$|^65329(_65329)*$|^65237(_65237)*$|^65218(_65218)*$|^65153(_65153)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65263(_65263)*$|^65116(_65116)*$|^65112(_65112)*$|^65114(_65114)*$|^65378(_65378)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65105(_65105)*$|^65296(_65296)*$|^65211(_65211)*$|^65317(_65317)*$|^65115(_65115)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65371(_65371)*$|^65214(_65214)*$|^65325(_65325)*$|^65354(_65354)*$|^65384(_65384)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65220(_65220)*$|^65277(_65277)*$|^65219(_65219)*$|^65213(_65213)*$|^65336(_65336)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65249(_65249)*$|^65112(_65112)*$|^65314(_65314)*$|^65385(_65385)*$|^65152(_65152)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65196(_65196)*$|^65252(_65252)*$|^65162(_65162)*$|^65271(_65271)*$|^65357(_65357)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65317(_65317)*$|^65360(_65360)*$|^65198(_65198)*$|^65256(_65256)*$|^65246(_65246)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65356(_65356)*$|^65359(_65359)*$|^65302(_65302)*$|^65118(_65118)*$|^65346(_65346)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65225(_65225)*$|^65307(_65307)*$|^65313(_65313)*$|^65189(_65189)*$|^65288(_65288)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65381(_65381)*$|^65292(_65292)*$|^65145(_65145)*$|^65325(_65325)*$|^65361(_65361)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65156(_65156)*$|^65184(_65184)*$|^65367(_65367)*$|^65302(_65302)*$|^65290(_65290)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65351(_65351)*$|^65116(_65116)*$|^65341(_65341)*$|^65123(_65123)*$|^65258(_65258)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65397(_65397)*$|^65302(_65302)*$|^65188(_65188)*$|^65187(_65187)*$|^65358(_65358)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65217(_65217)*$|^65107(_65107)*$|^65203(_65203)*$|^65377(_65377)*$|^65381(_65381)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65219(_65219)*$|^65308(_65308)*$|^65364(_65364)*$|^65277(_65277)*$|^65396(_65396)*$') then
set med 80
endif
if as-path in (ios-regex '^65281(_65281)*$|^65336(_65336)*$|^65238(_65238)*$|^65381(_65381)*$|^65103(_65103)*$') then
set med 80
else
set med 90
endif
end-policy
這些輸出是在收到完整的Internet BGP表刻度後收集的，然後進一步傳播。
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#show pcl protocol bgp speaker-0 neighbor-in-dflt default-IPv4-Uni-10.0.54.6 policy profile
Policy profiling data
Policy : INGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
Pass : 720100
Drop : 0
# of executions : 720100
Total execution time : 30119msec <============== about 30 seconds to process ingress updates
Node Id Num visited Exec time Policy engine operation
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PXL_0_1 720100 4434msec if as-path aspath-match ... then
PXL_0_2 361 0msec set local-preference 150
PXL_0_3 720100 3039msec if as-path aspath-match ... then
--- removed lines ---
GOTO : PXL_0_3
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1#show pcl protocol bgp speaker-0 neighbor-out-dflt default-IPv4-Uni-UpdGrp-0.3-Out policy profile
Policy profiling data
Policy : EGRESS-ROUTE-POLICY
Pass : 720110
Drop : 0
# of executions : 720110
Total execution time : 106566msec <============== about 1.8 minutes to process egress updates
Node Id Num visited Exec time Policy engine operation
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
PXL_0_1 720110 2958msec if as-path aspath-match ... then
PXL_0_2 0 0msec set med 70
PXL_0_3 720110 5222msec if as-path aspath-match ... then
PXL_0_4 3 0msec set med 80
PXL_0_5 720110 4979msec if as-path aspath-match ... then
PXL_0_6 set med 80
--- removed lines ---
GOTO : PXL_0_3
RP/0/RSP1/CPU0:XR1# 結論
使用本機as-path匹配或摺疊正規表示式模式可以提高路由策略的效能。
修訂記錄
| 修訂 | 發佈日期 | 意見 |
|---|---|---|
2.0 |
31-Jan-2022
|
次要編輯 |
1.0 |
14-Jan-2022
|
初始版本 |
意見