Guest

iQ MAGAZINE

Rural Schools Improve Communication

Cisco Systems and Data Eclipse help a school district in rural Ohio deploy a converged wireless IP Communcations network.
By Eric J. Adams
Photograph by Drew Endicott

Article Contents:
The Wayne Trace Local School District is about as rural as they come. It serves only around 1,100 students from kindergarten through 12th grade, yet it covers 180 square miles of mostly farmland in northwestern Ohio.

Not surprisingly, the three-school district doesn't have a lot of money. And until recently, its budget woes were aggravated by a telecommunications quirk that placed the district at the intersection of not two but three telephone companies.

"That meant that every intra-district call was a long-distance charge, and some parents were charged long-distance rates each time they called district offices or even their own child's school," says Rob Wannemacher, the district's treasurer.

The school's antiquated private branch exchange (PBX) phone system also led to an inordinate number of busy signals and staff time spent scribbling down messages and chasing down employees, because teachers and administrators did not have individual voice-mail boxes.

At the same time, the schools suffered costly and sometimes debilitating data network problems. The district's main computing hub is not in the school district, but at a regional data-acquisition site in Lima, Ohio, some 50 miles way. As a result, the district was forced to maintain three expensive and underutilized T-1 lines, one for each school. Any time data was sent between schools, it was routed through Lima, according to Jo Ellen Sisson, Wayne Trace's district technology coordinator.

Worst of all, the T-1 lines were expensive to maintain, slow, and often unreliable, causing frequent interruptions.

Last November, the district replaced both its aging traditional voice and data systems with a converged wireless Cisco Internet Protocol (IP) Communications network, designed and deployed by Data Eclipse, a Cisco SMB Select Partner located in Bryan, Ohio.

Back to top

First-Class Services
The district began reaping the benefits of its new converged voice-and-data IP network immediately. Most importantly, it eliminated the long-distance toll charges on calls between the different sites on the district's network. The IP Communications system provided robust calling features for every district employee, such as unified e-mail and voice-mail boxes, easy call forwarding for ad hoc classroom changes, guaranteed line access, and extension dialing between buildings.

"For the first time, we have telephones in every classroom, and that's a big plus for security," says Wannemacher.

Additionally, all incoming calls are billed as local calls because they come through local lines at each building and then are routed through the IP network. On the data side, all school servers are centrally located for easy maintenance, and data speeds reach 54 Mbps, compared to 1.5 Mbps with the T-1 lines.

The district will save nearly $40,000 over the next five years by eliminating T-1 leasing costs, approximately $2,000 per year in reduced long-distance charges, and thousands more in reduced network maintenance costs, according to Wannemacher.

Towering Implementation
At first, the district planned to address its telephone and data needs separately. It had gone so far as to request two bids in early 2004—one for a replacement PBX phone system and another for data switches from Cisco Systems. Then Data Eclipse president Dan Glore and Cisco education representative John Ford "showed us how a single network would lower both our hard costs and continuing maintenance and telecommunications costs," says Wannemacher.

Once convinced that a converged IP network was the best option, the district briefly considered the idea of running fiber-optic cable between the schools, but at a total of 20 miles apart, the estimate came to approximately $500,000.

As a much more affordable alternative, Data Eclipse then proposed connecting all the sites using a wireless wide-area network (WAN). Deployment of the Cisco IP network was broken into three parts: the wireless building-to-building connectivity, the switches between the local-area network (LAN) and the WAN, and the IP Communicatons system. The deployment began in November of 2003 and lasted approximately six months.

Many town residents came out to watch as a Data Eclipse team assembled and installed a 100-foot-tall tower near each of the three network sites. Once the towers were in place, Data Eclipse installed Cisco radios with directional dish antennae to act as data replicators, buried a conduit from each building to its tower, and finally connected each building's LAN to the radios. Cisco engineers worked closely with Data Eclipse throughout the process. "Cisco was there from the first pre-bid meeting through the final deployment, helping to validate the design, and providing product support," says Glore.

Back to top

Local Booster
The deployment was finished in the summer of 2004, but the work wasn't over. To ensure a smooth transition, Data Eclipse conducted on-site training for the district's technical staff, as well as additional training to select non-technical employees who serve as on-site experts.

"We've worked previously with Data Eclipse and learned then that the company is a great fit for us because they are neighbors and provide one-stop-shop expertise," says Wannemacher.

The district is now hoping to take further advantage of its converged network. "The next step is for us to create a wireless environment internally. But as for the underlying network, we feel we're set for the next 15 years," says Sisson.

The lesson of the implementation, she adds, is that you don't have to be a big-city corporation to fund and build a state-of-theart converged wireless network.

"Innovation isn't reserved for large organizations," says Sisson. "It can happen anywhere."

Back to top

iQ Magazine, First Quarter 2005

About the Author
Eric J. Adams whose work has appeared in publications such as The New York Times, The Los Angeles Times, and Wired, writes regularly about business trends and solutions.
Download this Article
Rural Schools Improve Communication [79 KB]

Further Reading
Team Players
From Cisco
Next Steps

Team Players
Mission: Cisco Systems and Data Eclipse, a Cisco SMB Select Partner, provide expertise in converged data, voice, and video networking to deliver strategic and financial benefits to a wide range of public- and private-sector organizations.

Strategies: The strategic relationship is built on Cisco's leadership in developing intelligent IP Communications infrastructure solutions for businesses of all sizes, combined with Data Eclipse's expertise with small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs), on-site project management, solution development, and consulting.

Programs: Cisco and Data Eclipse develop joint initiatives and implementation teams that take advantage of Cisco's scalable networking technology and Data Eclipse's IT networking, IP Communications, wireless, security, and solutions integration designed for SMBs.


From Cisco: Cisco IP Communications Enhances Campus Efficiency
Many school districts, colleges, and universities are replacing aging private branch exchange (PBX) telecommunications systems with Cisco IP Communications and the flexibility and functionality it delivers.

With Cisco IP Communications, data, voice, and video communications share a single converged network. This simplifies network management for IT personnel and can reduce operating expenses by avoiding toll charges on calls between sites on the network and eliminating the costly rewiring normally required with PBX systems.

While these benefits are important, Cisco IP Communications' enhanced functionality is what makes it an effective productivity tool for educators. Using an application developed for IP phones, teachers can take attendance and send a report directly to the office over the network, which eliminates the need for office personnel to input paper-based attendance information.

"Now we know by 8:15 in the morning exactly which students have excused and unexcused absences, and the phone calls home to inquire about unexcused absences are made hours earlier," says Robert Yost, director of Information Technology for Frederick County Public Schools in northern Virginia, where the school district has deployed a Cisco IP Communications system equipped with an attendance application developed by Cisco Premier Certified Partner AAC Inc. "It's saved us a lot of time on data entry, we no longer have to purchase card stock, and the school secretaries can spend their time on other important school business."

In addition, Cisco IP Communications allows school officials to make public address announcements from any IP phone on the network and makes it possible for all employees to have unified voice- and e-mail services.

With productivity-enhancing features such as these, it's clear why educational professionals at institutions of all sizes are transforming their telecommunications systems with Cisco IP Communications.—Ewan Morrison


Next Steps
Learn more about Cisco solutions for education customers.

Learn more about Cisco IP Communications solutions for small and medium-sized organizations.

Find a Cisco reseller in your area.