Table Of Contents
School Safety and Security with the Cisco SAFE Security ArchitectureLast Updated: November 20, 2009
Document AuthorMartin Pueblas, CCIE#2133, CISSP#40844—Technical Leader, CMO Enterprise Solutions Engineering (ESE), Cisco Systems
Martin is the lead system architect of the Cisco SAFE Security Reference Architecture. He is a network security expert with over 17 years of experience in the networking industry. He obtained his CCIE certification in 1996 and CISSP in 2004. Martin joined Cisco in 1998 and has held a variety of technical positions. Started as a Customer Support Engineer in Cisco's Technical Assistance Center (TAC) in Brussels, Belgium. In 1999 moved to the United States where soon became technical leader for the Security Team. Martin's primary job responsibilities included acting as a primary escalation resource for the team and delivering training for the support organization. At the end of 2000, he joined the Advanced Engineering Services team as a Network Design Consultant, where he provided design and security consulting services to large corporations and Service Providers. During this period, Martin has written a variety of technical documents including design guides and white papers that define Cisco's best practices for security and VPNs. Martin joined Cisco's Central Marketing Organization in late 2001, where as a Technical Marketing Engineer, he focused on security and VPN technologies. In late 2004, he joined his current position acting as a security technical leader. As part of his current responsibilities, Martin is leading the development of security solutions for enterprises.
School Safety and Security with the Cisco SAFE Security Architecture
Schools are one of the most fundamental institutions that support our communities and influence the future of our society. Providing a safe and secure environment is a top responsibility for school administrators and community leaders.
Schools, like many other institutions, are not immuned to safety incidents such as violence, vandalism, theft, abductions, and natural disasters. On the other hand, as schools embrace new communication and collaboration tools, transitioning from traditional classroom teaching into Internet-based media-rich education and learning, a whole new set of challenges arise. Without adequate protection, schools may be threatened by harmful or inappropriate content that could put the well-being of the students at risk, the theft of student records and private data, the loss of school network and service availability, as well as the abuse of internal applications and network resources.
A safe school is one that successfully uses the right tools to ensure the safety and security of students, staff and faculty, and guarantees the immediate and effective response to security and safety incidents. The most effective strategy is one that combines physical and network controls, not in isolation but rather in collaboration and with a common purpose. Whether it is network security, video surveillance, or unified communication services, it is the convergence of these solutions that delivers the best results.
Adding further reasons to focus on school safety and security, federal and state governments have enacted a number of regulations designed to protect the privacy of student records and to limit the exposure of children to harmful online content. For example, in the USA, schools and libraries under federal funding are required to comply with the Children's Internet Protection Act (CIPA) and Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA). These regulations require schools and libraries to implement the necessary measures to protect children from harmful content, and to guarantee the privacy of student and parent records.
This document describes how the Cisco Service Ready Architecture (SRA) for Schools sets the foundation for safe and secure schools by leveraging the proven design and deployment guidelines of the Cisco SAFE Security Architecture. The Schools SRA is a well-designed and validated network architecture that enables schools to deliver all of the services required for an enhanced learning environment. Cisco SAFE is a security reference architecture that provides detailed design and implementation guidelines for organizations looking to build highly secure and reliable networks.
Common Threats to School Environments
Due to the affluence of students, staff and faculty, school environments may be subject to violence, theft, vandalism, and other threats. The adoption of new network collaboration and Internet-based technologies also opens the possibility for a number of cyber threats. Understanding the nature and diversity of these threats, and how they may evolve over time, is the first step towards a successful school safety and security strategy. The following are some of the common threats to school environments:
•Safety incidents—Violence, bullying, theft, vandalism, abductions, terrorist threats, natural disasters that threatens students, staff, faculty and property.
•Service disruption—Disruption of the administrative infrastructure and learning resources such as computer labs caused by botnets, worms, malware, adware, spyware, viruses, DoS attacks.
•Harmful or inappropriate content—Pornography, adult, aggressive, offensive and other type of content that could put the physical and psychological well-being of minors at risk.
•Network abuse—Peer-to-peer file sharing and instant messaging abuse, use of non-approved applications by students, staff and faculty.
•Unauthorized access—Intrusions, unauthorized users, escalation of privileges, and unauthorized access to learning and administrative resources.
•Data loss—Theft or leakage of student, staff and faculty private data from servers, endpoints, while in transit, or as a result of spyware, malware, key-loggers, viruses, etc.
School Security Design
The Schools SRA is a validated network architecture designed around both school operations and technical considerations. Recognizing the fact cost is a common limiting factor to the School SRA designs, the architecture topologies and platforms were carefully selected to increase productivity while reducing overall costs.
The architecture design accommodates a school district office and multiple school sites of various sizes, all interconnected over a Metro Ethernet core. The architecture design is illustrated in Figure 1.
At the heart of the architecture is a robust routing and switching network. Operating on top of this network are the all services used within the school district office, such as safety and security systems, voice communications, and video surveillance to name a few. The core of those services are deployed and managed at the district office, allowing each school to reduce the need for separate services to be operated and maintained by school personnel. Centralized systems and applications are served by a district office data center.
Figure 1 Secure School Design
The architecture is designed with security to provide a safe online environment for teaching and learning. Following the proven guidelines of the Cisco SAFE security architecture, a series of network security technologies and products are strategically deployed throughout the network to protect minors from harmful and inappropriate content, to guarantee the confidentiality of student, staff and faculty private data, and to ensure the availability and integrity of systems and data. Video surveillance systems are deployed across the school premises to monitor activity and to prevent and deter safety incidents. Unified communication services are used for emergency response, enhanced 911 support, training, and emergency planning.
As shown in Figure 1, the solution design follows a defense-in-depth approach, where multiple layers of protection are built into the architecture. The different safety and security tools are combined together for enhanced visibility and control.
The security design of the architecture focuses on the following key areas:
•Network Foundation Protection (NFP)
–Ensuring the availability and integrity of the network infrastructure, protecting the control and management planes.
•Internet Perimeter Protection
–Ensuring safe Internet connectivity, and protecting internal resources and users from malware, viruses, and other malicious software.
–Protecting students, staff, and faculty from harmful and inappropriate content.
–Enforcing E-mail and web browsing policies.
•Data Center Protection
–Ensuring the availability and integrity of centralized applications and systems.
–Protecting the confidentiality and privacy of student, staff, and faculty records.
•Network Access Security and Control
–Securing the access edges. Enforcing authentication and role-based access for students, staff, and faculty residing at school sites and district office.
–Ensuring systems are up-to-date and in compliance with the school network security policies.
•Network Endpoint Protection
–Protecting servers and school-controlled systems (computer labs, school-provided laptops, etc.) from viruses, malware, botnets, and other malicious software.
–Preventing and deterring safety threats by monitoring and analyzing activity at the school premises.
•Unified Communication Services
–Facilitating the agile response to safety and security incidents by leveraging phone, video, digital signage, and conferencing services.
Note "Appendix F—Cisco Security Services" section describes the security services available in support of the entire solution lifecycle.
The following subsections discuss the key areas of the architecture security design.
Network Foundation Protection
School networks are built with routers, switches, and other network devices that keep the applications and services running. Therefore, properly securing these network devices is critical for continued operation.
The Schools SRA protects the network infrastructure by implementing the Cisco SAFE best practices for the following areas:
•Infrastructure device access
–Restrict management device access to authorized parties and for the authorized ports and protocols.
–Enforce Authentication, Authorization and Accounting (AAA) with TACACS+ or RADIUS to authenticate access, authorize actions and log all administrative access.
–Display legal notification banners.
–Ensure confidentiality by using secure protocols like SSH and HTTPS.
–Enforce idle and session timeouts. Disable unused access lines.
–Restrict routing protocol membership by enabling MD5 neighbor authentication and disabling default interface membership.
–Enforce route filters to ensure that only legitimate networks are advertised; and networks that are not supposed to be propagated are never advertised.
–Log status changes of neighbor sessions to identify connectivity problems and DoS attempts on routers.
•Device resiliency and survivability
–Disable unnecessary services, implement control plane policing (CoPP).
–Enable traffic storm control.
–Implement topological, system and module redundancy for the resiliency and survivability of routers and switches and to ensure network availability.
–Keep local device statistics.
–Enable NTP time synchronization.
–Collect system status and event information with SNMP, Syslog, TACACS+/RADIUS accounting.
–Monitor CPU and memory usage on critical systems.
•Network policy enforcement
–Implement access edge filtering.
–Enforce IP spoofing protection with access control lists (ACLs), Unicast Reverse Path Forwarding (uRPF), and IP Source Guard.
–Implement a hierarchical design, segmenting the LAN into multiple IP subnets or VLANS to reduce the size of broadcast domains.
–Protect the Spanning Tree Protocol (STP) domain with BPDU Guard and STP Root Guard.
–Use per-VLAN Spanning Tree to reduce the scope of possible damage.
–Disable VLAN dynamic trunk negotiation on user ports.
–Disable unused ports and put them into an unused VLAN.
–Implement Catalyst Infrastructure Security Features (CISF) including port security, dynamic ARP inspection, DHCP snooping.
–Use a dedicated VLAN ID for all trunk ports.
–Explicitly configure trunking on infrastructure ports.
–Use all tagged mode for the native VLAN on trunks and drop untagged frames.
–Ensure the secure management of all devices and hosts within the school network architecture.
–Authenticate, authorize, and keep record of all administrative access.
–If possible, implement a separate out-of-band (OOB) management network (hardware or VLAN based) to manage systems local at the district office.
–Secure the OOB by enforcing access controls, using dedicated management interfaces or VRFs.
–Provide secure in-band management access for systems residing at the school sites by deploying firewalls and ACLs to enforce access controls, using Network Address Translation (NAT) to hide management addresses, and using secure protocols like SSH and HTTPS.
–Ensure time synchronization by using NTP.
–Secure servers and other endpoint with endpoint protection software and operating system (OS) hardening best practices.
For more information on the management strategy, refer to "Chapter 9, Management" of the Cisco SAFE Reference Guide at the following URL:
For more detailed information on the NFP best practices, refer the "Chapter 2, Network Foundation Protection" of the Cisco SAFE Reference Guide at the following URL:
Internet Perimeter Protection
The school architecture assumes the existence of a centralized Internet connection at the district office, serving students, staff and faculty residing at all school premises. Common services typically provided include E-mail for staff and faculty, Internet browsing for everyone, and a school web portal accessible over the Internet. Other services may also be provided using the same infrastructure.
The network infrastructure that provides Internet connectivity is defined as the Internet perimeter, illustrated in Figure 2.
Figure 2 Internet Perimeter
The primary functions of the Internet perimeter is to allow for safe and secure access for students, staff and faculty, and to provide public services without compromising the confidentiality, integrity and availability of school resources and data. To that end, the Internet perimeter incorporates the following security functions:
•Internet Border Router—The Internet border router is the Internet gateway responsible for routing traffic between the school and the Internet. The Internet border router may be administered by school personnel or may be managed by the Internet service provider (ISP). The router provides the first line of protection against external threats and should be hardened following the Network Foundation Protection (NFP) best practices.
•Internet Firewall—A Cisco ASA provides stateful access control and deep packet inspection to protect school resources and data from unauthorized access and disclosure. The security appliance is configured to prevent incoming access from the Internet, to protect the school web portal and other Internet public services, and to control student, staff, and faculty traffic bound to the Internet. The security appliance may also implement an Advanced Inspection and Prevention Security Services Module (AIP SSM) for enhanced threat detection and mitigation. This IPS module may be configured either in inline or promiscuous mode. The security appliance may also provide secure remote access to faculty, staff, and students in the form of IPSec or SSL VPN.
•Public Services DMZ— The Internet school web portal, mail server and other public-facing services may be placed on a demilitarized zone (DMZ) for security and control purposes. The DMZ acts as a middle stage between the Internet and school's private resources, preventing external users from directly accessing any internal servers and data. The Internet firewall is responsible for restricting incoming access to the public services and by limiting outbound access from DMZ resources out to the Internet. Systems residing on the DMZ are hardened with endpoint protection software (i.e., Cisco Security Agent) and operating system (OS) hardening best practices.
•E-mail Security—A Cisco Ironport C Series E-mail Security Appliance (ESA) is deployed at the DMZ to inspect incoming and outgoing E-mails and eliminate threats such as E-mail spam, viruses and worms. The ESA appliance also offers E-mail encryption to ensure the confidentiality of messages, and data loss prevention (DLP) to detect the inappropriate transport of sensitive information.
•Web Security—A Cisco IronPort S Series Web Security Appliance (WSA) is deployed at the distribution switches to inspect HTTP and HTTPS traffic bound to the Internet. This system enforces URL filtering policies to block access to websites containing content that may be harmful or inappropriate for students or that are known to be the source of spyware, botnets or other type of malware. The WSA may also be configured to block certain Internet applications such as AOL Messenger, BitTorrent, Skype, etc. The WSA is also responsible for the monitoring of Layer-4 traffic for rogue activity and infected systems.
Following are the design guidelines for implementing the security functions.
Note For implementation details on Remote Access VPN, CSA, and Internet border router hardening please refer to the Cisco SAFE Reference Guide. Firewall, IPS, and web security configurations and deployment details can be found in the deployment appendices of this document.
Internet Border Router Security Guidelines
The Internet border router provides connectivity to the Internet through one or more Internet service providers. The router act as the first line-of-defense against unauthorized access, DDoS, and other external threats. Access control lists (ACLs), uRPF, and other filtering mechanisms may be implemented for anti-spoofing and to block invalid packets. NetFlow, Syslog, SNMP may be used to gain visibility on traffic flows, network activity and system status. In addition, the Internet border router should be secured following the practices explained in the "Network Foundation Protection" section. This includes restricting and controlling administrative access, protecting the management and control planes, and securing the dynamic exchange of routing information.
The "Appendix A—Internet Border Router Deployment" section provides an example of Internet edge ACL. For more information on how to configure the Internet border router, refer to the "Chapter 6, Enterprise Internet Edge" of the Cisco SAFE Reference Guide at the following URL:
Internet Firewall Guidelines
The Cisco ASA deployed at the Internet perimeter is responsible for protecting the school's internal resources and data from external threats by preventing incoming access from the Internet. protecting public resources served by the DMZ by restricting incoming access to the public services and by limiting outbound access from DMZ resources out to the Internet, and controlling user's Internet-bound traffic.
To that end, the security appliance is configured to enforce access policies, keep track of connection status, and inspect packet payloads following these guidelines:
•Deny any connection attempts originating from the Internet to internal resources and subnets.
•Allow outbound Internet HTTP/HTTPS access for students, staff and faculty residing at any of the school premises.
•Allow outbound Internet SSL access for administrative updates, SensorBase, IPS signature updates, etc.
•Allow students, staff and faculty access to DMZ services such as school web portal, E-mail, and domain name resolution (HTTP, SMTP, POP, IMAP, and DNS).
•Restrict inbound Internet access to the DMZ for the necessary protocols and servers (HTTP to web server, SMTP to the mail transfer agent, DNS to DNS server, etc.).
•Restrict connections initiated from DMZ to the only necessary protocols and sources (DNS from DNS server, SMTP from the mail server, HTTP/SSL from Cisco IronPort ESA).
•Enable stateful inspection for the used protocols to ensure returning traffic is dynamically allowed by the firewall.
•Implement Network Address Translation (NAT) and Port Address Translation (PAT) to shield the internal address space from the Internet.
Figure 3 illustrates the protocols and ports explicitly allowed by the Cisco ASA.
Figure 3 Allowed Protocols and Ports
Note Figure 3 does not include any management traffic destined to the firewall. Whenever available, a dedicated management interface should be used. In case the firewall is managed in-band, identify the protocols and ports required prior to configuring the firewall ACLs.
In addition, the Cisco ASA should be hardened following the NFP best practices. This includes restricting and controlling administrative access, securing the dynamic exchange of routing information with MD5 authentication, and enabling firewall network telemetry with SNMP, Syslog, and NetFlow.
In the school design, high availability is achieved by using redundant physical interfaces. This represents the most cost-effective solution for high availability. As an alternative, a pair of firewall appliances could be deployed in stateful failover, as discussed in the "Appendix B—Internet Firewall Deployment" section.
E-mail Security Guidelines
The Cisco Ironport C Series E-mail Security Appliance (ESA) deployed at the DMZ is responsible for inspecting E-mails and eliminating threats such as E-mail spam, viruses, and worms. The ESA can be described as a firewall and threat monitoring system for Simple Mail Transfer Protocol (SMTP) traffic (TCP port 25). Logically speaking, the ESA acts as a Mail Transfer Agent (MTA) within the E-mail delivery chain, as illustrated in Figure 4. Upon reception, E-mails are evaluated using a reputation score mechanism based on the SensorBase network. The SensorBase network is an extensive network that monitors global E-mail and web traffic for anomalies, viruses, malware and other and abnormal behavior. The network is composed of Cisco IronPort appliances, Cisco ASA and Cisco IPS appliances and modules installed in more than 100,000 organizations worldwide, providing a large and diverse sample of Internet traffic patterns. By leveraging the SensorBase Network, messages originating from domain names or servers known to be the source of spam or malware, and therefore with a low reputation score, are automatically dropped or quarantined by preconfigured reputation filters. Optionally, the school may choose to implement some of the other functions offered by the ESA appliance, including anti-virus protection with virus outbreak filters and embedded anti-virus engines (Sophos and McAfee), encryption to ensure the confidentiality of messages, and data loss prevention (DLP) for E-mail to detect the inappropriate transport of sensitive information.
Note Alternatively, Cisco offers managed hosted and hybrid hosted E-mail security services. These services are provided through a dedicated E-mail infrastructure hosted in a network of Cisco data centers. For more information, refer to http://www.cisco.com/go/designzone.
Figure 4 E-mail Delivery Chain
Note Figure 4 shows a logical implementation of a DMZ hosting the E-mail server and ESA appliance. This can be implemented physically by either using a single firewall or two firewalls in sandwich.
There are multiple deployment approaches for the security appliance depending on the number of interfaces used (see Figure 5):
•Dual-armed configuration—Two physical interfaces used to serve a public mail listener and a private mail listener, each one configured with a separate logical IP address. The public listener receives E-mail from the Internet and directs messages to the internal E-mail servers; while the private listener receives E-mail from the internal servers and directs messages to the Internet. The public listener interface may connect to the DMZ, while the public listener interface may connect to the inside of the firewall.
•One-armed configuration—A single ESA interface configured with a single IP address and used for both incoming and outgoing E-mail. A public mail listener is configured to receive and relay E-mail on that interface. The best practice is to connect the ESA interface to the DMZ where the E-mail server resides.
For simplicity, the school architecture implements the ESA with a single interface. In addition, using a single interface leaves other data interfaces available for redundancy.
Figure 5 Common ESA Deployments
Figure 6 illustrates the logical location of the ESA within the E-mail flow chain.
Figure 6 Typical Data Flow for Inbound E-mail Traffic
The following steps explain what is taking place in Figure 6:
Step 1 Sender sends an E-mail to xyz@domain X.
Step 2 What's the IP address of domain X?
Step 3 It's a.b.c.d (public IP address of ESA).
Step 4 E-mail server sends message to a.b.c.d using SMTP.
Step 5 Firewall permits incoming SMTP connection to the ESA, and translates its public IP address.
Step 6 ESA performs a DNS query on sender domain and checks the received IP address in its reputation database, and drops, quarantines E-mail based on policy.
Step 7 ESA forwards E-mail to preconfigured inbound E-mail server.
Step 8 E-mail server stores E-mail for retrieval by receiver.
Step 9 Receiver retrieves E-mail from server using POP or IMAP.
The Internet firewall should be configured to allow communications to and from the Cisco IronPort ESA. Protocols and ports to be allowed vary depending on the services configured on the appliance. For details, refer to the Cisco IronPort User's Guide at the following URL: http://www.ironport.com/support/
The following are some of the most common services required:
•Outbound SMTP (TCP/25) from ESA to any Internet destination
•Inbound SMTP (TCP/25) to ESA from any Internet destination
•Outbound HTTP (TCP/80) from ESA to downloads.ironport.com and updates.ironport.com
•Outbound SSL (TCP/443) from ESA to updates-static.ironport.com and phonehome.senderbase.org
•Inbound and Outbound DNS (TCP and UDP port 53)
•Inbound IMAP (TCP/143), POP (TCP/110), SMTP (TCP/25) to E-mail server from any internal client
In addition, if the ESA is managed in-band, appropriate firewall rules need to be configured to allow traffic such as SSH, NTP, and syslog.
The Cisco IronPort ESA appliance functions as a SMTP gateway, also known as a mail exchange (MX). The following are the key deployment guidelines:
•Ensure that the ESA appliance is both accessible via the public Internet and is the first hop in the E-mail infrastructure. If you allow another MTA to sit at your network's perimeter and handle all external connections, then the ESA appliance will not be able to determine the sender's IP address. The sender's IP address is needed to identify and distinguish senders in the Mail Flow Monitor, to query the SensorBase Reputation Service for the sender's SensorBase Reputation Service Score (SBRS), and to improve the efficacy of the anti-spam and virus outbreak filters features.
•Features like Cisco IronPort Anti-Spam, Virus Outbreak Filters, McAfee Antivirus and Sophos Anti-Virus require the ESA appliance to be registered in DNS. To that end, create an A record that maps the appliance's hostname to its public IP address, and an MX record that maps the public domain to the appliance's hostname. Specify a priority for the MX record to advertise the ESA appliance as the primary (or backup during testing) MTA for the domain. A static address translation entry needs to be defined for the ESA public IP address on the Internet firewall if NAT is configured.
•Add to the Recipient Access Table (RAT) all the local domains for which the ESA appliance will accept mail. Inbound E-mail destined to domains not listed in RAT will be rejected. External E-mail servers connect directly to the ESA appliance to transmit E-mail for the local domains, and the ESA appliance relays the mail to the appropriate groupware servers (for example, Exchange™, Groupwise™, and Domino™) via SMTP routes.
•For each private listener, configure the Host Access Table (HAT) to indicate the hosts that will be allowed to send E-mails. The ESA appliance accepts outbound E-mail based on the settings of the HAT table. Configuration includes the definition of Sender Groups associating groups or users, upon which mail policies can be applied. Policies include Mail Flow Policies and Reputation Filtering. Mail Flow Policies are a way of expressing a group of HAT parameters (access rule, followed by rate limit parameters and custom SMTP codes and responses). Reputation Filtering allows the classification of E-mail senders and to restrict E-mail access based on sender's trustworthiness as determined by the IronPort SennsorBase Reputation Service.
•Define SMTP routes to direct E-mail to appropriate internal mail servers.
•If an out-of-band (OOB) management network is available, use a separate interface for administration.
A failure on the ESA appliance may cause service outage, therefore a redundant design is recommended. There are multiple ways to implement redundancy:
•IronPort NIC Pairing—Redundancy at the network interface card level by teaming two of the Ethernet interfaces on the ESA appliance. If the primary interface fails, the IP addresses and MAC address are assumed by the secondary.
•Multiple MTAs—Consists in adding a second ESA appliance or MTA with an equal cost secondary MX record.
•Load Balancer—A load balancer such as Cisco ACE Application Control Engine (ACE) load-balances traffic across multiple ESA appliances.
IronPort NIC pairing is the most cost-effective solution (see Figure 7), because it does not require the implementation of multiple ESA appliances and other hardware. It does not, however, provide redundancy in case of chassis failure.
Figure 7 Cisco IronPort ESA NIC pairing
For more information on how to configure ESA, refer to the Cisco SAFE Reference Guide (http://www.cisco.com/en/US/docs/solutions/Enterprise/Security/SAFE_RG/SAFE_rg.html) and IronPort ESA User's Guide (http://www.ironport.com/support/).
Web Security Guidelines
The school architecture implements a Cisco IronPort S Series Web Security Appliance (WSA) to block access to sites with content that may be harmful or inappropriate for minors, and to protect the schools from web-based malware and spyware.
Cisco IronPort WSA's protection relies in two independent services:
•Web Proxy—This provides URL filtering, web reputation filters, and optionally anti-malware services. The URL filtering capability defines the handling of each web transaction based on the URL category of the HTTP requests. Leveraging the SensorBase network, the web reputation filters analyze the web server behavior and characteristics to identify suspicious activity and protect against URL-based malware. The anti-malware service leverages anti-malware scanning engines such as Webroot and McAfee to monitor for malware activity.
•Layer 4 Traffic Monitoring (L4TM)—Service configured to monitor all Layer-4 traffic for rogue activity and to detect infected clients.
Note The SensorBase network is an extensive network that monitors global E-mail and web traffic for anomalies, viruses, malware, and other abnormal behavior. The network is composed of the Cisco IronPort appliances, Cisco ASA, and Cisco IPS appliances and modules installed in more than 100,000 organizations worldwide, providing a large and diverse sample of Internet traffic patterns.
As the school design assumes a centralized Internet connection, the WSA is implemented at the distribution layer of the district office network. This allows the inspection and enforcement of web access policies to all students, staff, and faculty residing at any of the school premises. Logically, the WSA sits in the path between web users and the Internet, as shown in Figure 8.
Figure 8 Cisco IronPort WSA
There are two deployment modes for the Web Proxy service:
•Explicit Forward Proxy—Client applications, such as web browsers, are aware of the Web Proxy and must be configured to point to the WSA. The web browsers can be either configured manually or by using Proxy Auto Configuration (PAC) files. The manual configuration does not allow for redundancy, while the use of PAC files allows the definition of multiple WSAs for redundancy and load balancing. If supported by the browser, the Web Proxy Autodiscovery Protocol (WPAD) can be used to automate the deployment of PAC files. WPAD allows the browser to determine the location of the PAC file using DHCP and DNS lookups.
•Transparent Proxy—Client applications are unaware of the Web Proxy and do not have to be configured to connect to the proxy. This mode requires the implementation of a Web Cache Communications Protocol (WCCP) enable device or a Layer-4 load balancer in order to intercept and redirect traffic to the WSA. Both deployment options provide for redundancy and load balancing.
Explicit forward proxy mode requires the school to have control over the configuration of the endpoints, which may not be always possible. For example, the school may allow students, staff and faculty to use personal laptops, smart-phones and other devices outside the school's administration. Transparent proxy mode, on the other hand, provides a transparent integration of WSA without requiring any configuration control over the endpoints. It also eliminates the possibility of users reconfiguring their web browsers to bypass the appliance without knowledge of the administrators. For these reasons, the school architecture implements transparent proxy with WCCP. In this configuration, the Cisco ASA at the Internet perimeter is leveraged as a WCCP server while the WSA act as a WCCP Traffic Processing Entity.
Note It is recommended to enable both the Layer-4 traffic monitor and transparent proxy during the initial System Setup Wizard. Either of these services can be disabled or reconfigured after initial setup from the web interface. If you do not enable one of the features in the System Setup Wizard and then need to enable it later, you must run the System Setup Wizard again, losing all configurations added to the appliance.
The Cisco ASA uses WCCP version 2, which has a built-in failover and load balancing mechanism. Per WCCPv2 specification, multiple appliances (up to 32 entities) can be configured as part of the same service group. HTTP and HTTPS traffic is load-balanced across the active appliances based on source and destination IP addresses. The server (Cisco ASA) monitors the availability of each appliance in the group, and can identify appliance failures within 30 seconds. After failure, traffic is redirected across the remaining active appliances. In the case no appliances are active, WCCP takes the entire service group offline and subsequent requests bypass redirection. In addition, WCCPv2 supports MD5 authentication for the communications between WCCP server and WSA appliances.
Note In the event the entire service group fails, WCCP automatically bypasses redirection, allowing users to browse the Internet without the Web controls. In case it is desired to handle a group failure by blocking all traffic, an outbound ACL may be configured on the Cisco ASA outside interface to permit HTTP/HTTPS traffic originated from the WSA appliance itself and to block any direct requests from clients. The ACL may also have to be configured to permit HTTP/HTTPS access from IPS and other systems requiring such access.
WCCPv2 supports Generic Route Encapsulation (GRE) and Layer-2-based redirection; however, the Cisco ASA only supports GRE. In addition, WCCP is supported only on the ingress of an interface. The only topology supported is one where both clients and WSA are reachable from the same interface, and where the WSA can directly communicate with the clients without going through the Cisco ASA. For these reasons, the WSA appliance is deployed at the inside segment of the Cisco ASA.
Figure 9 illustrates the how WCCP redirection works in conjunction with Cisco ASA.
Figure 9 WCCP Redirection
The following steps describe what takes place in Figure 9:
Step 1 Client's browser requests connection to http://website.com.
Step 2 Cisco ASA intercepts and redirects HTTP requests over GRE.
Step 3 If content not present in local cache, WSA performs a DNS query on destination domain and checks the received IP address against URL and reputation rules, and allows/denies request accordantly.
Step 4 WSA fetches content from destination web site.
Step 5 Content is inspected and then delivered directly to the requesting client.
The WSA appliance may also be configured to control and block peer-to-peer file-sharing and Internet applications such as AOL Messenger, BitTorrent, Skype, Kazaa, etc. The way WSA handles these applications depends on the TCP port used for transport:
•Port 80—Applications that use HTTP tunneling on port 80 can be handled by enforcing access policies within the web proxy configuration. Application access may be restricted based on applications, URL categories, and objects. Applications are recognized and blocked based on their user agent pattern, and by the use of regular expressions. The user may also specify categories of URL to block, including the predefined chat and peer-to-peer categories. Custom URL categories may also be defined. Peer-to-peer access may also be filtered based on object and MIME Multipurpose Internet Mail Extensions (MIME) types.
•Ports other than 80—Applications using ports other than 80 can be handled with the L4TM feature. L4TM block access to a specific application by preventing access to the server or block of IP addresses to which the client application must connect.
Note In the school design, the Cisco ASA is configured to allow only permitted ports (HTTP and HTTPS), so any connection attempts on other ports should be blocked by the firewall.
Note The Cisco IPS appliances and modules, and the Cisco ASA (using the modular policy framework), may also be used to block peer-to-peer file sharing and Internet applications.
The following are the guidelines for implementing a Cisco IronPort WSA appliance with WCCP on a Cisco ASA:
•Deploy WSA on the inside of the firewall so that the WSA can communicate with the clients without going through the firewall.
•Implement MD5 authentication to protect the communications between the Cisco ASA and the WSA(s).
•Configure a redirect-list on the firewall to indicate what traffic needs to be redirected. Make sure the WSA is always excluded from redirection.
•Ingress ACL on the firewall takes precedence over WCCP redirection, so make sure the ingress ACL is configured to allow HTTP and HTTPS traffic from clients and the WSA itself.
•In an existing proxy environment, deploy the WSA downstream from the existing proxy servers (closer to the clients).
•Cisco ASA does not support WCCP IP source address spoofing, therefore any upstream authentication or access controls based on client IP addresses are not supported. Without IP address spoofing, requests originating from a client are sourced with the IP address of the Web Proxy, and not the one of the client.
•TCP intercept, authorization, URL filtering, inspect engines, and IPS features do not apply to redirected flows of traffic served by the WSA cache. Content requested by the WSA is still subject to all the configured features on the firewall.
•Configure WSA access policies to block access to applications (AOL Messenger, Yahoo Messenger, BitTorrent, Kazaa, etc) and URL categories not allowed by the school's Internet access policies.
•If an out-of-band (OOB) management network is available, use a separate interface for administration.
Note WCCP, firewall, and other stateful features usually require traffic symmetry, whereby is traffic in both directions should flow through the same stateful device. The school architecture is designed with a single Internet path ensuring traffic symmetry. Care should be taken when implementing active-active firewall pairs as they may introduce asymmetric paths.
The Layer-4 Traffic Monitor (L4TM) service is deployed independently from the Web Proxy functionality, and its mission is to monitor network traffic for rogue activity and for any attempts to bypass port 80. L4TM works by listening to all UDP and TCP traffic and by matching domain names and IP addresses against entries in its own database tables to determine whether to allow incoming and outgoing traffic. The L4TM internal database is continuously updated with matched results for IP addresses and domain names. Additionally, the database table receives periodic updates from the IronPort update server (https://update-manifests.ironport.com).
The following are the key guidelines when deploying the L4 Traffic Monitor:
•Determine physical connection—L4TM requires traffic to be directed to the WSA for monitoring. This can be done by connecting a physical network tap, configuring SPAN port mirroring on a switch, or using a hub. Network taps forward packets in hardware, while SPAN port mirroring is generally done in software. On the other hand, SPAN port mirroring can be easily reconfigured, providing further flexibility.
•Location—Deploy L4TM in the network where it can see as much traffic as possible before getting out to the Internet through the firewall. It is important that the L4TM be logically connected after the proxy ports and before any device that performs network address translation (NAT) on client IP addresses.
•Action setting—The default setting for the L4TM is monitor only. Optionally you may configure the L4TM to monitor and block suspicious traffic. TCP connections are reset with the generating of TCP resets, while UDP sessions are tear down with ICMP unreachables. The use of L4TM blocking requires that the L4TM and the Web Proxy to be placed on the same network so that all clients are accessible on routes that are configured for data traffic.
In the school architecture, L4TM is deployed by setting a SPAN session on the distribution switch to replicate all TCP and UDP traffic on the links connecting to the inside interface of the firewall. Using SPAN provides greater flexibility, and inspecting the firewall's inside links ensures traffic is monitored before NAT and before being sent out the Internet. The L4TM deployment is shown in Figure 10.
Figure 10 L4TM Deployment
L4TM action is set to monitor only. Because the Internet firewall is configured to block any traffic bound to the Internet other than HTTP and HTTPS, there is no additional benefit in using L4TM blocking. If active mitigation is required, consider implementing a Cisco IPS module or appliance in in-line mode. When deployed in inline mode, the Cisco IPS is placed in the traffic path and is capable of stopping malicious traffic before it reaches the intended target. In addition, the Cisco IPS provides multiple configurable response actions including blocking the malicious packet only, blocking the entire session, or blocking any traffic coming from the offending system.
Configuration steps and examples are included in the "Appendix D—Web Security Deployment" section.
Data Center Protection
School district offices typically implement a data center that hosts the systems that serve the administrative and educational applications and store the data accessible to internal users. The infrastructure supporting them may include application servers, the storage media, routers, switches, load balancers, off-loaders, application acceleration devices and other systems.
The data center may also host the following foundational services as part of the school architecture:
•Identity and Security Services— NAC management server and Cisco ACS appliance.
•Unified Communication Services— Emergency responder, unified call-manager, presence server, and voice gateway.
•Mobility Services— Mobility service engine, WLAN controller, and wireless control system.
•Video Services— Video surveillance server, video surveillance operations manager, video surveillance virtual matrix server, and digital media manager.
•Partner Applications— Partner DMS notification server and partner context-ware application.
Depending on the size of the school district, the data center may be constructed following different design models. Figure 11 illustrates a collapsed design, and the less common for schools, multi-tier design. In the collapsed design all services are hosted in a shared physical serverfarm, and high availability is achieved by using redundant processors and interfaces. Very large school districts may implement a more enterprise-like data center following a multi-tier design with chassis redundancy.
Figure 11 Data Center Designs
Independently from the design model adopted by the school, the following are the primary security guidelines for the data center design:
•Network Foundation Protection— All infrastructure equipment should be protected following the Network Foundation Protection best practices described earlier in this document. This includes restricting and controlling administrative access, protecting the management and control planes, and securing the switching and routing planes.
•Firewall—A stateful firewall may be deployed to limit access to only the necessary applications and services, and for the intended users. The firewall should be configured to control and inspect both traffic entering and leaving the server farm segments. The firewall may also be leveraged to ensure the appropriate segregation between application layers or groups. In addition, the firewall's deep packet inspection may be used to mitigate DoS attacks and enforce protocol compliance.
•Intrusion Prevention— An IPS module on the Cisco ASA or a separate IPS appliance may be implemented for enhanced threat detection and mitigation. The IPS is responsible for identifying and blocking anomalous traffic and packets recognized as well-known attacks. The Cisco IPS may be configured either in inline or promiscuous mode. When deployed in inline mode, the Cisco IPS is placed in the traffic path and is capable of stopping malicious traffic before it reaches the intended target.
•Service Isolation— Services and applications serving different group of users or under different security requirements should be properly isolated. Isolation helps prevent data leakage and contain possible compromises from spreading across different server farm groups. Logical isolation may be achieved by separating applications and services in different VLANs and by assigning them into different firewall interfaces (physical or logical). This is illustrated in Figure 12.
•Switch Security—Private VLANs, port security, storm control and other switch security features may be leveraged to mitigate spoofing, man-in-the-middle, denial-of-service and other network-based attacks directed to the data center applications and the switching infrastructure.
•Endpoint Protection— Servers residing at the different layers should be protected with host-based IPS or other endpoint security software.
Figure 12 Service Isolation
SSL termination and inspection, Web Application Firewall (WAF), Application Control Engine (ACE), and other solutions may be leveraged to complement the guidelines described above. For a more detailed discussion of data center security, refer to "Chapter 4, Intranet Data Center" of the Cisco SAFE Reference Guide at the following URL:
Network Access Security and Control
Some of the most vulnerable points of the network are the access edges where students, staff, and faculty connect to the network. With the proliferation of wireless networks, increased use of laptops and smart mobile devices, the school administration cannot simply rely on physical controls hoping to prevent unauthorized systems from being plugged into the ports of the access switches. Protection should rather be embedded into the network infrastructure, leveraging the native security features available in switches, routers, and WLAN system. Furthermore, the network infrastructure should also provide dynamic identity or role-based access controls for all systems attempting to gain access.
Implementing role-based access controls for users and devices helps reduce the potential loss of sensitive information by enabling schools to verify a user or device identity, privilege level, and security policy compliance before granting network access. Security policy compliance could consist of requiring antivirus software, OS updates or patches. Unauthorized or noncompliant devices can be placed in a quarantine area where remediation can occur prior to gaining access to the network.
The school architecture achieves access security and control by leveraging the following technologies:
•Catalyst Integrated Security Features (CISF)—Wired
•Cisco Unified Wireless Network (CUWN) Integrated Security Features—Wireless
•Cisco NAC Appliance—Wired and wireless
•Cisco Identity-Based Network Networking Services (IBNS)—Wired and wireless
The CISF is a set of native security features available on Cisco Catalyst Switches and designed to protect the access infrastructure and users from spoofing, man-in-the-middle, DoS and other network-based attacks. CISF includes features such as private VLANs, port security, DHCP snooping, IP Source Guard, secure Address Resolution Protocol (ARP) detection, and Dynamic ARP Inspection (DAI). CISF features are considered to be part of a security baseline and should be deployed on all access ports.
The Cisco Unified Wireless Network adds to the 802.11 security standards by providing additional security features. Some of these are the WLAN equivalent of CISF features such as, Dynamic Host Configuration Protocol (DHCP) and Address Resolution Protocol (ARP) protection, peer-to-peer blocking, and access control list and firewall features. Additionally, other more WLAN-specific features are provided, including enhanced WLAN security options, wireless intrusion detection system (IDS), client exclusion, rogue AP detection, management frame protection, dynamic radio frequency management, and network IDS integration.
In addition to using the CISF features to secure the access ports, access control solutions like IBNS or NAC appliance may be deployed to control who can access the network and ensure endpoint compliance with the schools security policies.
The Cisco IBNS solution is a set of Cisco IOS software services designed to enable secure user and host access to enterprise networks powered by Cisco Catalyst switches and wireless LANs. It provides standards-based network access control at the access layer by using the 802.1X protocol to secure the physical ports where end users connect. 802.1X is an IEEE standard for media-level (Layer 2) access control, offering the capability to permit or deny network connectivity based on the identity of the end user or device enabling enterprise policy enforcement of all users and hosts, whether managed or unmanaged. In addition to holistic access-control provided by 802.1X, IBNS also offers device-specific access-control through MAC-Authentication Bypass (MAB) and user-based access-control through Web-Auth.
The Cisco Network Admission Control (NAC) Appliance uses the network infrastructure to enforce security policy compliance on all devices seeking to access network computing resources. With NAC Appliance, network administrators can authenticate, authorize, evaluate, and remediate wired, wireless, and remote users and their machines prior to network access. It identifies whether networked devices such as laptops, IP phones, or game consoles are compliant with your network's security policies and repairs any vulnerability before permitting access to the network. Noncompliant machines are redirected into a quarantine area, where remediation occurs at the discretion of the administrator.
The choice of which access control solution to use depends on the security goals and the direction of the network design. For networks using or moving towards 802.1x-based wired or wireless access and interested in identity-based access control, Cisco IBNS solution should be considered. For networks requiring role-based access control using posture assessments to ensure security compliance, Cisco NAC Appliance should be considered.
The Catalyst Integrated Security Features (CISF), and the Cisco Identity-Based Networking Services (IBNS) and NAC Appliance access control solutions are discussed in "Chapter 9, Access Layer Security Design" of the Cisco Service Ready Architecture for Schools Design Guide.The Cisco Unified Wireless Network solutions are discussed in "Chapter 5, Wireless LAN Design" of the Cisco Service Ready Architecture for Schools Design Guide. For details, refer to the Cisco Service Ready Architecture for Schools Design Guide at the following URL:
Additional information about the CUWN security features can be found in the Wireless and Network Security Integration Solution Design Guide at the following URL:
The "Appendix E—CISF Protected Ports" section provides a configuration example for an access port secured using the Catalyst Integrated Security features.
Servers, desktop computers, laptops, printers, and IP phones are examples of the diverse network endpoints commonly present in school environments. The great variety in hardware types, operating systems, and applications represents a clear challenge to security. In addition, students, staff and faculty may bring laptops and other portable devices that could also be used outside the school premises, potentially introducing viruses, worms, spyware and other type of malware.
Properly securing the endpoints requires not only adoption of the appropriate technical controls but also end-user awareness. While this document focuses on the implementation of the technical controls, the school's security strategy must include security awareness campaigns and programs. Students, staff and faculty must be continuously educated on current threats, Internet-use best practices, and the security measures needed for keeping endpoints up-to-date with the latest updates, patches, and fixes.
Following the guidelines of Cisco SAFE, the school architecture implements a range of security controls designed to protect the endpoints. These include Cisco host-based IPS, network-based intrusion prevention systems, and web and E-mail traffic security.
As a Cisco host-based IPS, the architecture leverages the Cisco Security Agent (CSA) on end-user workstations and servers. CSA takes a proactive and preventative approach, using behavior-based security to focus on preventing malicious activity on the host. Malicious activity is detected and blocked, independent of the type of malware, spyware, adware, or virus affecting the host.
Once deployed on an endpoint, whenever an application attempts an operation, the agent checks the operation against the application's security policy—making a real-time allow or deny decision on the continuation of that operation and determining whether logging the operation request is appropriate. Security policies are collections of rules that IT or security administrators assign to protect servers and desktops, either individually or organization-wide. CSA provides defense-in-depth protection against spyware and adware by combining security policies that implement distributed firewall, operating system lockdown and integrity assurance, malicious mobile code protection, and audit-event collection capabilities in default policies for servers and desktops.
CSAs are centrally managed with the CSA Management Center (CSA-MC), which in the Cisco SAFE design is placed in a secure segment in the data center. The Management Center (MC) also provides centralized reporting and global correlation.
For complete details about deploying CSA in a network, refer to the Rapid Deployment Guide for Cisco Security Agent 6.0 for Desktops at the following URL:
Cisco Video Surveillance
IP-based video surveillance systems are deployed throughout the school district to monitor and analyze activity at all school premises with the intention to prevent and deter safety incidents. The video surveillance system provides first responders and school staff real-time information, vital to determine the appropriate and timely response to safety incidents.
Video analytics provide responders and officials with enhanced intelligence. Predefined policies can be configured to produce alerts and trigger specific response mechanisms, for example when an individual is identified loitering or leaving behind a package. Video content is stored on digital media and can reside locally at the school or within the district office. In addition, content generated at the school sites may be centrally aggregated and analyzed at the school district office.
For detailed design and deployment recommendations for video surveillance, refer to the following documents:
•IP Video Surveillance Design Guide
•Cisco Digital Media System 5.1 Design Guide for Enterprise Medianet
Cisco Unified Communications Services and Alerting
The school architecture takes advantage of IP-based telephony, video, digital signage, and conferencing services to facilitate the agile response to safety and security incidents. The Cisco Unified Communications systems are therefore deployed throughout the school premises.
IP-based telephony services provide teachers and staff one-touch access to security and emergency services, facilitate the identification of the exact location of call origin, and deliver-enhanced 911 support. In addition, automatic text and voice notification can be configured to be broadcast to IP phones, speakers, and paging systems.
Cisco conferencing and collaboration services provide instant meeting capabilities via audio and web collaboration in the event of an emergency, helping share critical information such as disaster recovery plans, maps, images, and more. Conferencing and collaboration systems may also be used to quickly and easily share emergency messages with students, teachers, and parents using internal and external broadcast messaging.
Digital Signage is a centrally controlled system that allows schools to leverage their existing networks to deliver video content to digital signs located within the school.
These signs can be used to display simple content such as the menu of the day, or act as information boards in the event of an emergency. The digital signage system can be leveraged to deliver immediate information regarding a school safety event to ensure the appropriate response from student, teachers and staff.
The implementation and design of Cisco Unified Communication Services and alerting is described in detail in the "Unified Communications Design in Schools" chapter of the Schools SRA Design Guide.
The success of the safety and security tools and measures in place ultimately depends on the degree they enhance visibility and control. Simply put, security can be defined as a function of visibility and control. Without any visibility, it is difficult to enforce any control, and without any control it is hard to achieve an adequate level of security. Therefore, the safety and security tools selected in the school design were carefully chosen not only to mitigate certain threats but also to increase the overall visibility and control.
Table 1 summarizes how the safety and security tools and measures used in the school design help mitigate certain threats, and how they contribute to increasing visibility and control. Please note the table is provided for illustration purposes and it is not intended to include all possible safety and security tools, and threats.
Appendix A—Internet Border Router Deployment
Whether the Internet border router is managed by the school or the ISP, it must be hardened following the best practices listed in the "Network Foundation Protection" section. This includes restricting and controlling administrative access, protecting the management and control planes, and securing the dynamic exchange of routing information. In addition, the Internet border router may be leveraged as the first layer of protection against outside threats. To that end, edge ACLs, uRPF and other filtering mechanisms may be implemented for anti-spoofing and to block invalid packets.
The following configuration snippet illustrates the structure of an edge ACL applied to the upstream interface of the Internet border router. The ACL is designed to block invalid packets and to protect the infrastructure IP addresses from the Internet. The configuration assumes the school is assigned the 188.8.131.52/24 address block for its public-facing services, and that the upstream link is configured in the 184.108.40.206/24 subnet.! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!--- Module 1: Anti-spoofing Denies!--- These ACEs deny fragments, RFC 1918 space,!--- invalid source addresses, and spoofs of!--- internal space (space as an external source).!!--- Deny fragments.access-list 110 deny tcp any 220.127.116.11 0.0.0.255 fragmentsaccess-list 110 deny udp any 18.104.22.168 0.0.0.255 fragmentsaccess-list 110 deny icmp any 22.214.171.124 0.0.0.255 fragments!--- Deny special-use address sources.!--- See RFC 3330 for additional special-use addresses.access-list 110 deny ip host 0.0.0.0 anyaccess-list 110 deny ip 127.0.0.0 0.255.255.255 anyaccess-list 110 deny ip 192.0.2.0 0.0.0.255 anyaccess-list 110 deny ip 126.96.36.199 188.8.131.52 any!--- Filter RFC 1918 space.access-list 110 deny ip 10.0.0.0 0.255.255.255 anyaccess-list 110 deny ip 172.16.0.0 0.15.255.255 anyaccess-list 110 deny ip 192.168.0.0 0.0.255.255 any!--- Deny packets spoofing the school's public addressesaccess-list 110 deny ip 184.108.40.206 0.0.0.255 any!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!--- Module 2: Explicit Permit!--- Permit only applications/protocols whose destination!--- address is part of the infrastructure IP block.!--- The source of the traffic should be known and authorized.!!--- Permit external BGP to peer 220.127.116.11access-list 110 permit tcp host 18.104.22.168 host 22.214.171.124 eq bgpaccess-list 110 permit tcp host 126.96.36.199 eq bgp host 188.8.131.52!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!--- Module 3: Explicit Deny to Protect Infrastructureaccess-list 110 deny ip 184.108.40.206 0.0.0.255 any!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!--- Module 4: Explicit Permit for Traffic to School's Public!--- Subnet.access-list 110 permit ip any 220.127.116.11 0.0.0.255!
Note The 18.104.22.168/16 and 22.214.171.124/24 address blocks used in the examples in this document are reserved for the exclusive use of Cisco Systems, Inc.
Appendix B—Internet Firewall Deployment
The mission of the Internet firewall is to protect the school's internal resources and data from external threats, secure the public services provided by the DMZ, and to control user's traffic to the Internet. The school architecture uses a Cisco ASA appliance as illustrated in Figure 13.
Figure 13 Internet Edge Firewall
The Cisco ASA is implemented with three interface groups, each one representing a distinct security domain:
•Inside—The interface connecting to the core/distribution switch that faces the interior of the network where internal users and resources reside.
•Outside—Interface connecting to the Internet border router. The router may be managed either by the school or a service provider.
•Demilitarized Zone (DMZ)—The DMZ hosts school services that are accessible over the Internet. These services may include a web portal and E-mail services.
The Internet firewall acts as the primary gateway to the Internet; therefore, its deployment should be carefully planned. The following are key aspects to be considered when implementing the firewall:
•Firewall hardening and monitoring
•Network Address Translation (NAT)
•Firewall access policies
Firewall Hardening and Monitoring
The Cisco ASA should be hardened in a similar fashion as the infrastructure routers and switches. According to the Cisco SAFE security best practices, the following is a summary of the measures to be taken:
•Implement dedicated management interfaces to the OOB management network.
•Present legal notification for all access attempts.
•Use HTTPS and SSH for device access. Limit access to known IP addresses used for administrative access.
•Configure AAA for role-based access control and logging. Use a local fallback account in case AAA server is unreachable.
•Use NTP to synchronize the time.
•Use syslog or SNMP to keep track of system status, traffic statistics, and device access information.
•Authenticate routing neighbors and log neighbor changes.
•Implement firewall access policies (explained in Firewall Access Policies).
The Cisco ASA 5510 and higher appliance models come with a dedicated management interface that should be used whenever possible. Using a dedicated management interface keeps the management plane of the firewall isolated from threats originating from the data plane. The management interface should connect to the OOB management network, if one is available.
The following is an example of the configuration of a dedicated management interface.interface Management0/0nameif managementsecurity-level 100ip address 172.26.160.225 255.255.252.0management-only!
Note Any physical interface or logical sub-interface can be configured as a management-only interface using the management-only command.
It is recommended that a legal notification banner is presented on all interactive sessions to ensure that users are notified of the security policy being enforced and to which they are subject. The notification banner should be written in consultation with your legal advisors.
The following example displays the banner after the user logs in:banner motd UNAUTHORIZED ACCESS TO THIS DEVICE IS PROHIBITED.banner motd You must have explicit, authorized permission to access or configure this device.banner motd Unauthorized attempts and actions to access or use this system may result in civil and/or criminal penalties.banner motd All activities performed on this device are logged and monitored.
Management access to the firewall should be restricted to SSH and HTTPS. SSH is needed for CLI access and HTTPS is needed for the firewall GUI-based management tools such as CSM and ADSM. Additionally, this access should only be permitted for users authorized to access the firewalls for management purposes.
The following ASA configuration fragment illustrates the configuration needed to generate a 768 RSA key pair and enabling SSH and HTTPS access for devices located in the management subnet.! Generate RSA key pair with a key modulus of 768 bitscrypto key generate rsa modulus 768! Save the RSA keys to persistent flash memorywrite memory! enable HTTPShttp server enable! restrict HTTPS access to the firewall to permitted management stationshttp <CSM/ADSM-IP-address> 255.255.255.255 management! restrict SSH access to the firewall to well-known administrative systemsssh <admin-host-IP-address> 255.255.255.255 management! Configure a timeout value for SSH access to 5 minutesssh timeout 5
Administrative users accessing the firewalls for management must be authenticated, authorized, and access should be logged using AAA. The following ASA configuration fragment illustrates the AAA configurations needed to authenticate, authorize, and log user access to the firewall:aaa-server tacacs-servers protocol tacacs+reactivation-mode timedaaa-server tacacs-servers host <ACS-Server>key <secure-key>aaa authentication ssh console tacacs-servers LOCALaaa authentication serial console tacacs-servers LOCALaaa authentication enable console tacacs-servers LOCALaaa authentication http console tacacs-servers LOCALaaa authorization command tacacs-servers LOCALaaa accounting ssh console tacacs-serversaaa accounting serial console tacacs-serversaaa accounting command tacacs-serversaaa accounting enable console tacacs-serversaaa authorization exec authentication-server! define local username and password for local authentication fallbackusername admin password <secure-password> encrypted privilege 15
As with the other infrastructure devices in the network, it is important to synchronize the time on the firewall protecting the management module using NTP.
The following configuration fragment illustrates the NTP configuration needed on an ASA to enable NTP to an NTP server located in the management network:ntp authentication-key 10 md5 *ntp authenticatentp trusted-key 10ntp server <NTP-Server-address> source management
Syslog and SNMP can be used to keep track of system status, device access and session activity. NetFlow Security Event Logging (NSEL), now supported on all Cisco ASA models, may also be used for the monitoring and reporting of session activity. The following configuration fragment illustrates the configuration of Syslog.logging trap informationallogging host management <Syslog-Server-address>logging enable
The routing protocol running between the Internet firewall and the distribution/core should be secured. The following ASA configuration fragment illustrates the use of EIGRP MD5 authentication to authenticate the peering session between the inside firewall interface and the core/distribution switch:interface Redundant1nameif insidesecurity-level 100ip address 10.125.33.10 255.255.255.0authentication key eigrp 100 <removed> key-id 1authentication mode eigrp 100 md5
Network Address Translation (NAT)
NAT is required because the school typically gets a limited number of public IP addresses. In addition, NAT helps shield the school's internal address space from reconnaissance and another malicious activity.
The following illustrates the NAT configuration:! Static translation for servers residing at DMZstatic (dmz,outside) 126.96.36.199 10.25.34.10 netmask 255.255.255.255static (dmz,outside) 188.8.131.52 10.25.34.11 netmask 255.255.255.255static (dmz,outside) 184.108.40.206 10.25.34.12 netmask 255.255.255.255static (dmz,outside) 220.127.116.11 10.25.34.13 netmask 255.255.255.255!! Dynamic Port Address Translation (PAT) for inside hosts going to the Internetglobal (outside) 10 interfacenat (inside) 10 10.0.0.0 255.0.0.0!! Static translation for inside hosts going to the DMZ and vice-versa. The inside IP addresses are visible to the DMZ.static (inside,dmz) 10.0.0.0 10.0.0.0 netmask 255.0.0.0
Firewall Access Policies
As previously explained, the Internet firewall should be configured to:
•Protect school internal resources and data from external threats by preventing incoming access from the Internet.
•Protect public resources served by the DMZ by restricting incoming access to the public services and by limiting outbound access from DMZ resources out to the Internet.
•Control user's Internet-bound traffic.
Enforcing such policies requires the deployment of ACLs governing what traffic is allowed or prevented from transiting between interfaces. By default the Cisco ASA appliance allows traffic from higher to lower security level interfaces (i.e., from inside to outside). However, due to the sensitivity of school environments, the school administration may opt to override the default rules with more stringent rules indicating exactly what ports and protocols are permitted.
It should also be noted that, as the Cisco ASA inspects traffic is able to recognize packets belonging to already established sessions. The stateful inspection engine of the firewall dynamically allows the returning traffic. Therefore, the firewall ACLs should be constructed to match traffic in the direction in which is being initiated. In our sample configurations ACLs are applied in the ingress direction.
The following are the guidelines and configuration examples of ACLs controlling access and traffic flows:
Allow Internet access to student, staff, and faculty residing at all school premises for the allowed ports and protocols. This typically includes HTTP and HTTPS access.access-list Outbound extended permit tcp 10.0.0.0 255.0.0.0 any eq httpaccess-list Outbound extended permit tcp 10.0.0.0 255.0.0.0 any eq https
Allow students, staff, and faculty access to DMZ services such as the school web portal, E-mail, and domain name resolution (HTTP, HTTPS, SMTP, POP, IMAP, and DNS). Note that the previous entries in the ACL already permit HTTP and HTTPS traffic.! Allow DNS queries to DNS serveraccess-list Outbound extended permit udp 10.0.0.0 255.0.0.0 host 10.25.34.13 eq domain! Allow SMTP, POP3 and IMAP access to DMZ mail serveraccess-list Outbound extended permit tcp 10.0.0.0 255.0.0.0 host 10.25.34.12 eq smtpaccess-list Outbound extended permit tcp 10.0.0.0 255.0.0.0 host 10.25.34.12 eq pop3access-list Outbound extended permit tcp 10.0.0.0 255.0.0.0 host 10.25.34.12 eq imap4! Apply ACL to inside interfaceaccess-group Outbound in interface inside
Restrict connections initiated from DMZ only to the only necessary protocols and sources. This typically includes DNS queries and zone transfer from DNS server, SMTP from E-mail server, HTTP/SSL access from the Cisco IronPort ESA for updates, Sensorbase, etc.! Allow DNS queries and zone transfer from DNS serveraccess-list DMZ extended permit udp host 10.25.34.13 any eq domainaccess-list DMZ extended permit tcp host 10.25.34.13 any eq domain!! Allow SMTP from Cisco IronPort ESAaccess-list DMZ extended permit tcp host 10.25.34.11 any eq smtp!! Allow update and SensorBase access to Cisco IronPort ESAaccess-list DMZ extended permit tcp host 10.25.34.11 any eq httpaccess-list DMZ extended permit tcp host 10.25.34.11 any eq https!! Apply ACL to DMZ interfaceaccess-group DMZ in interface dmz
Inbound Internet access should be restricted to the public services provided at the DMZ such as SMTP, web, and DNS. Any connection attempts to internal resources and subnets from the Internet should be blocked. ACLs should be constructed using the servers' global IP addresses.! Allow DNS queries and zone transfer to DNS serveraccess-list Inbound extended permit udp any host 18.104.22.168 eq domainaccess-list Inbound extended permit tcp any host 22.214.171.124 eq domain!! Allow SMTP to Cisco IronPort ESAaccess-list Inbound extended permit tcp any host 126.96.36.199 eq smtp!! Allow HTTP/HTTPS access to school public web portalaccess-list Inbound extended permit tcp any host 188.8.131.52 eq httpaccess-list Inbound extended permit tcp any host 184.108.40.206 eq https!! Apply ACL to outside interfaceaccess-group Inbound in interface outside
The Internet perimeter of the school architecture uses a single Cisco ASA appliance configured with redundant interfaces. The use of redundant interfaces makes the design resilient to link level failures, representing an affordable option for high availability. In cases where chassis redundancy is desirable, the school may consider deploying a pair of Cisco ASA appliances configured for stateful failover. Both active/active and active/standby failover modes are supported. While stateful failover protects against chassis failures, it requires the deployment of two identical Cisco ASA appliances and the adjustment of the topologies around the firewalls, so its deployment should be carefully planned.
This guide explains the use of redundant interfaces. For information on how to configure stateful failover, refer to the Cisco ASA 5500 Series Adaptive Security Appliances Configuration Guides at the following URL:
A Cisco ASA redundant interface is a logical interface that pairs two physical interfaces, called active and standby interfaces. Under normal operation the active interface is the only one passing traffic. The active interface uses the IP address defined at the redundant interface, and the MAC address of the first physical interface associated with the redundant interface. When the active interface fails, the standby interface becomes active and starts passing traffic. The same IP address and MAC address are maintained so that traffic is not disrupted. Figure 14 illustrates the concept of redundant interface
Figure 14 Cisco ASA Redundant Interface
The configuration of a redundant interface consists in the configuration of the physical interface parameters and the logical redundant interface. Physical parameters such as media type, duplex, and speed are still configured within the physical interface. IP address, interface name, routing protocols, security level are configured as part of the redundant interface. The following configuration example corresponds to Figure 14.! Physical interface and Ethernet parametersinterface GigabitEthernet0/0description Connected to cr24-4507-DOno nameifno security-levelno ip address!interface GigabitEthernet0/1description backup to cr24-4507-DOno nameifno security-levelno ip address!! Defines logical redundant interface associated with physical! interfaces. Configures IP and logical interface parameters.interface Redundant1description Connected to cr24-4507-DOmember-interface GigabitEthernet0/0member-interface GigabitEthernet0/1nameif insidesecurity-level 100ip address 10.125.33.10 255.255.255.0authentication key eigrp 100 <removed> key-id 1authentication mode eigrp 100 md5!
An interior gateway protocol, EIGRP in our configuration examples, is used for dynamic routing. The Internet firewall may participate in routing by learning the internal routes and by injecting a default route pointing to the Internet. The default route should be removed dynamically if the Internet connection becomes unavailable.
As part of the school architecture, two different approaches were validated for the injection of the default route:
•OSPF—The Cisco ASA appliance learns the default route from the Internet border router using OSPF. The default route is then redistributed into EIGRP, and from there propagated into the rest of the internal network.
•Static Route—The Cisco ASA appliance is configured with a static default route pointing to the Internet gateway. Object tracking is configured to dynamically remove the default route when the Internet connection becomes unavailable. The default route is redistributed into EIGRP, and from there propagated into the rest of the internal network.Injecting a default route with OSPF requires the configuration of an OSPF process between the Cisco ASA and the Internet border router, as illustrated in Figure 15 . If the router is managed by the ISP, the configuration will require coordination with the service provider. This scenario also requires the default route to be propagated over OSPF. The actual default route may originate from the Internet border router itself or somewhere in the ISP network.
Figure 15 Cisco ASA OSPF
The following are the guidelines for using OSPF for the injection of a default route:
•Whenever possible, use MD5 authentication to secure the routing session between the Cisco ASA and the Internet border router.
•Since NAT is configured on the Cisco ASA and the inside address space is not visible outside the firewall, there is no need to redistribute routes from the internal EIGRP into OSPF.
•Route redistribution from OSPF into the internal EIGRP should be limited to the default route only. No other routes should be propagated into EIGRP.
The following configuration snippet illustrates the routing configuration of the Cisco ASA appliance. The configuration includes the route redistribution from OSPF into EIGRP with the enforcement of a route-map allowing only the injection of the default route. MD5 authentication is used for OSPF, and the logging of neighbor status changes is enabled.! Permit default onlyaccess-list Inbound-Routes standard permit host 0.0.0.0!interface GigabitEthernet0/2ospf message-digest-key 1 md5 <removed>ospf authentication message-digest!route-map Inbound-EIGRP permit 10match ip address Inbound-Routes!router eigrp 100no auto-summarynetwork 10.125.33.0 255.255.255.0passive-interface defaultno passive-interface insideredistribute ospf 200 metric 1000000 2000 255 1 1500 route-map Inbound-EIGRP!router ospf 200network 220.127.116.11 255.255.255.0 area 100area 100 authentication message-digestlog-adj-changes!
Note The hello-interval and dead-interval OSPF timers can be adjusted to detect topological changes faster.
The other validated alternative for the default route injection is the definition of a static default route, which then can be redistributed into the internal EIGRP process. This is shown in Figure 16. This option does not require the configuration of the Internet border router.
Figure 16 Cisco ASA static route
It is highly recommended to use object tracking so the default route is removed when the Internet connection becomes unavailable. Without object tracking, the default route will be removed only if the outside interface of the appliance goes down. So there is a possibility that the default route may remain in the routing table even if the Internet border router becomes unavailable. To avoid that problem, the static default route can be configured with object tracking. This consists in associating the default route with a monitoring target. The Cisco ASA appliance monitors the target using ICMP echo requests. If an echo reply is not received within a specified time period, the object is considered down and the associated default route is removed from the routing table.
The monitoring target needs to be carefully selected. First, pick one that can receive and respond to ICMP echo requests sent by the Cisco ASA. Second, it is better to use a persistent network object. In the configuration example below the Cisco ASA monitors the IP address of the next hop gateway, which helps identifying if the Internet gateway goes down, but it will not help if the connection is lost upstream. If available, you may want to monitor a persistent network object located somewhere in the ISP network. Static route tracking can also be configured for default routes obtained through DHCP or PPPoE.
In the following configuration the IP address of the next hop gateway (18.104.22.168) is used as the monitoring target. The static default route is then redistributed into EIGRP.router eigrp 100no auto-summarynetwork 10.125.33.0 255.255.255.0passive-interface defaultno passive-interface insideredistribute static metric 1000000 2000 255 1 1500!route outside 0.0.0.0 0.0.0.0 22.214.171.124 1 track 10!sla monitor 1type echo protocol ipIcmpEcho 126.96.36.199 interface outsidesla monitor schedule 1 life forever start-time now!track 10 rtr 1 reachability
Note The frequency and timeout parameters of object tracking can be adjusted to detect topological changes faster.
Appendix C—Deploying IPS with the Cisco ASA
While the IPS functionality has not been validated as part of the Cisco Schools SRA, this appendix provides the guidelines necessary for integrating IPS on a Cisco ASA appliance using an Advanced Inspection and Prevention Security Services Module (AIP SSM).
The AIP SSM module is supported on Cisco ASA 5510 and higher platforms. The AIP SSM runs advanced IPS software that provides proactive, full-featured intrusion prevention services to stop malicious traffic, including worms and network viruses, before they can affect your network.
If desired, the AIP SSM module may participate in Cisco Global Correlation for further threat visibility and control. Once enabled, the participating IPS sensor (AIP SSM in this case) receives threat updates from the Cisco SensorBase Network at regular intervals. The Cisco SensorBase Network contains detailed information about known threats on the Internet, including serial attackers, Botnet harvesters, Malware outbreaks, and dark nets. The IPS uses this information to filter out the worst attackers before they have a chance to attack critical assets. It then incorporates the global threat data into its system to detect and prevent malicious activity even earlier.
In terms of how the AIP SSM integrates with the Cisco ASA, while the module runs a separate application from the security appliance; it is however integrated into the traffic flow. The AIP SSM does not contain any external interfaces itself (except for the management interface on the SSM only). When you identify traffic for IPS inspection on the adaptive security appliance, traffic flows through the adaptive security appliance and the AIP SSM in the following way:
Step 1 Traffic enters the adaptive security appliance.
Step 2 Firewall policies are applied.
Step 3 Traffic is sent to the AIP SSM over the backplane.
Step 4 The AIP SSM applies its security policy to the traffic and takes appropriate actions.
Step 5 Valid traffic (for inline mode only) is sent back to the adaptive security appliance over the backplane; the AIP SSM might block some traffic according to its security policy and that traffic is not passed on.
Step 6 VPN policies are applied (if configured).
Step 7 Traffic exits the adaptive security appliance.
The AIP SSM may be deployed in inline or promiscuous mode:
•Inline mode—This mode places the AIP SSM directly in the traffic flow (see Figure 17). No traffic that you identified for IPS inspection can continue through the adaptive security appliance without first passing through, and being inspected by the AIP SSM. This mode is the most secure because every packet that you identify for inspection is analyzed before being allowed through. Also, the AIP SSM can implement a blocking policy on a packet-by-packet basis. This mode, however, can affect throughput.
•Promiscuous mode—This mode sends a duplicate stream of traffic to the AIP SSM. This mode is less secure, but has little impact on traffic throughput. Unlike the inline mode, in promiscuous mode the AIP SSM can only block traffic by instructing the adaptive security appliance to shun the traffic or by resetting a connection on the adaptive security appliance. Also, while the AIP SSM is analyzing the traffic, a small amount of traffic might pass through the adaptive security appliance before the AIP SSM can shun it. Figure 17 shows the AIP SSM in promiscuous mode.
Figure 17 IPS Inline and Promiscuous Modes
The AIP SSM card may be configured to fail open or close when the module becomes unavailable. When configured to fail open, the adaptive security appliance allows all traffic through, uninspected, if the AIP SSM becomes unavailable. Per contrary, when configured to fail close, the adaptive security appliance blocks all traffic in case of an AIP SSM failure.
The following example illustrates how a Cisco ASA can be configured to divert all IP traffic to the AIP SSM in promiscuous mode, and to block all IP traffic if the AIP SSM card fails for any reason:access-list IPS permit ip any anyclass-map my-ips-classmatch access-list IPSpolicy-map my-ips-policyclass my-ips-classips promiscuous fail-closeservice-policy my-ips-policy global
Appendix D—Web Security Deployment
The Schools Service Ready Architecture implements a Cisco IronPort WSA at the core/distribution layer of the district office, as illustrated in Figure 18. The WSA is located at the inside of the Cisco ASA acting as the Internet firewall. That ensures that clients and WSA are reachable over the same inside interface of the firewall, and that the WSA can communicate with them without going through the firewall. At the same time, deploying the WSA at the core/distribution layer gives complete visibility to the WSA on the traffic before getting out to the Internet through the firewall.
Figure 18 WSA deployment
Following are the guidelines for the WSA configuration and deployment.
Initial System Setup Wizard
The WSA provides a browser-based system setup wizard that must be executed the first time the appliance is installed. The System Setup Wizard guides the user through initial system configuration such as network and security settings. It is critical to note that some of the initial settings cannot be changed afterwards without resetting the appliance's configuration to its factory defaults. Therefore, care should be taken in choosing the right configuration options. Plan not only for the features to be implemented immediately, but also for what that might be required in the future.
The following are some guidelines when running the System Setup Wizard:
•Deployment Options—Step 2 of the wizard gives the user the options to enable only L4 Traffic Monitoring, enable only Secure Web Proxy, or enable both functions. Select enable both Secure Web Proxy and L4 Traffic Monitor if you plan to use both functions.
•Proxy Mode—If the Secure Web Proxy function has been enabled, Step 2 of the wizard requires the user to choose between Forward and Transparent mode. It should be noted that a WSA appliance initially configured in Transparent mode can still be configured as a Forward Web Proxy, per contrary, the Transparent Web Proxy function is not available if the appliance is configured in Forward mode. Therefore, select Forward mode only if you certain that the Transparent mode will never be required.
Note The deployment and proxy mode options cannot be changed after the initial configuration without resetting the WSA appliance to its factory defaults. Plan your configuration carefully.
Interface and Network Configuration
The following need to be completed as part of the initial setup of the WSA appliance:
Step 1 Configuring network interfaces
Step 2 Adding routes
Step 3 Configuring DNS
Step 4 Setting time
Step 5 Working with upstream proxy (if present)
These settings are configured as part of an initial setup using the System Setup Wizard, but can be later modified by using the WSA Web-based GUI.
Configuring Network Interfaces
Independently from the model, all Cisco IronPort WSA appliances are equipped with six Ethernet interfaces as shown in Figure 19.
Figure 19 WSA Interfaces
The WSA interfaces are grouped for the following functions:
•Management—Interfaces M1 and M2 are out-of-band (OOB) management interfaces. However, only M1 is enabled. In the school architecture, interface M1 connects to the out-of-band management network. Interface M1 can optionally be used to handle data traffic in case the school does not have an out-band management network.
•Web Proxy—Interfaces P1 and P2 are Web Proxy interfaces used for data traffic. Only the P1 interface is used in the school architecture. P1 connects to the inside subnet of the firewall.
•L4 Traffic Monitor (L4TM)—T1 and T2 are the L4TM interfaces. The school design uses only the T1 interfaces. The T1 interface connects to a core/distribution switch port configured as the destination of the SPAN session used to capture traffic bound to the Internet.
Figure 20 illustrates the network topology around the WSA used in the Cisco validation lab.
Figure 20 WSA Network Topology
Figure 21 illustrate the IP address and hostname configurations for the interfaces used. In this case, an out-of-band management network is used; therefore the M1 port is configured with an IP address in the management subnet. In addition, the WSA is configured to maintain a separate routing instance for the M1 management interface. This allows the definition of a default route for management traffic separate from the default route used for data traffic.
Figure 21 WSA Interface Configuration
A default route is defined for management traffic pointing to the OOB management default gateway (172.26.191.1). A separate default route is defined for the data traffic pointing to the inside IP address of the firewall (10.125.33.10). As all internal networks are reachable throughout the core/distribution switch, a route to 10.0.0.0/8 is defined pointing to the switch IP address (10.125.33.9) to allow the WSA to communicate with the clients directly without having to go to the firewall first. These settings are illustrated in Figure 22.
Figure 22 WSA Route Configuration
The initial setup requires the configuration of a host name for the WSA appliance, and listing the DNS servers. Figure 23 shows the DNS configuration.
Figure 23 WSA DNS Configuration
Time synchronization is critical for forensic analysis and troubleshooting, therefore enabling NTP is highly recommended. Figure 24 shows how the WSA is configured to synchronize its clock with an NTP server located on the OOB management network.
Figure 24 WSA NTP Configuration
Working with Upstream Proxies
Figure 25 WSA Upgrade Settings
Figure 26 WSA Component Updates
WCCP Transparent Web Proxy
The configuration of the WCCP Transparent Web Proxy includes the following:
Step 1 Defining WSA WCCP Service Group
Step 2 Enabling WSA Transparent Redirection
Step 3 Enabling WCCP redirection on the Cisco ASA
Step 4 Enabling WSA HTTPS scanning
Step 5 Working with upstream proxy (if present)
Defining WSA WCCP Service Group
Web Proxy settings are configured as part of an initial setup using the System Setup Wizard and can be later modified with the WSA Web-based GUI. The Web Proxy setting include the following:
•HTTP Ports to Proxy—List the ports to be proxied. Default is 80 and 3128.
•Caching—Defines whether or not the WSA should cache response and requests. Caching helps reduce latency and the load on the Internet links. Default is enabled.
•IP Spoofing — Defines whether or not the Web Proxy should spoof IP addresses when forwarding requests to upstream proxies and servers. The Cisco ASA does not support source address spoofing.
Figure 27 illustrates the Web Proxy settings.
Figure 27 WSA Proxy Settings
Enabling WSA Transparent Redirection
Configuring WCCP Transparent Redirection requires the definition of a WCCP service profile in the WSA. If redirecting HTTP and HTTPS, define a dynamic service ID to be used with the Cisco ASA. Use MD5 authentication to protect the WCCP communication between the WSA and Cisco ASA. Figure 28 shows an example.
Figure 28 WSA Transparent Proxy
Enabling WCCP Redirection on Cisco ASA
The configuration of WCCP on the Cisco ASA appliance requires:
•A group-list indicating the IP addresses of the appliances member of the service group. In the example provided below the group-list is called wsa-farm.
•A redirect-list indicating the ports and subnets of traffic to be redirected. In the example, the ACL named proxylist is configured to redirect any HTTP and HTTPS traffic coming from the 10.0.0.0/8 subnet. It is critical to ensure traffic from the WSA(s) bypasses redirection. To that end, add an entry to the redirect-list explicitly denying traffic sourced from the WSA(s).
•WCCP service indicating the service ID. Make sure you use the same ID as defined on the WSAs. Use a password for MD5 authentication.
•Enabling WCCP redirection on an interface. Apply the WCCP service on the inside interface of the Cisco ASA.
Cisco ASA WCCP configuration example:! Group-list defining the IP addresses of all WSAsaccess-list wsa-farm extended permit ip host 10.125.33.8 any!! Redirect-list defining what ports and hosts/subnets should be redirectedaccess-list proxylist extended deny ip host 10.125.33.8 anyaccess-list proxylist extended permit tcp 10.0.0.0 255.0.0.0 any eq wwwaccess-list proxylist extended permit tcp 10.0.0.0 255.0.0.0 any eq https!! WCCP servicewccp 10 redirect-list proxylist group-list wsa-farm password cisco!! Applies WCCP on an interfacewccp interface inside 10 redirect in
The WCCP connection status and configuration can be monitored on the Cisco ASA with the show wccp command. An example is provided below:cr26-asa5520-do# show wccpGlobal WCCP information:Router information:Router Identifier: 188.8.131.52Protocol Version: 2.0Service Identifier: 10Number of Cache Engines: 1Number of routers: 1Total Packets Redirected: 428617Redirect access-list: proxylistTotal Connections Denied Redirect: 0Total Packets Unassigned: 4Group access-list: wsa-farmTotal Messages Denied to Group: 0Total Authentication failures: 0Total Bypassed Packets Received: 0cr26-asa5520-do#
Step 4 - Enabling WSA HTTPS Scanning
To monitor and decrypt HTTPS traffic, you must enable HTTPS scanning on the WSA. The HTTPS Proxy configuration is illustrated in Figure 29.
Figure 29 WSA HTTPS Proxy
Working with Upstream Proxies
In case Internet traffic is handled by one or more upstream proxies, follow these guidelines:
•Add an Upstream Proxy Group
•Define a routing policy to direct traffic to the upstream proxies
The Upstream Proxy Group lists the IP addresses or domain names of the proxies to be used for traffic sent to the Internet. When multiple proxies are available, the WSA can be configured for failover or load balancing.
The following are the options available:
•None (failover)—The first proxy in the list is used. If one proxy cannot be reached, the Web Proxy attempts to connect to the next one in the list.
•Fewest connections—Transactions are directed to the proxy servicing the fewest number of connections.
•Hash-based—Requests are distributed using a hush function. The function uses the proxy ID and URL as inputs so that requests for the same URL are always directed to the same upstream proxy.
•Least recently used—Transactions are directed to the proxy that least recently received a transaction if all proxies are currently active.
•Round robin—The Web Proxy cycles transactions equally among all proxies in the group in the listed order.
Figure 30 illustrates the upstream proxy group configuration. Two upstream proxies are used, and transactions are forwarded to the proxy servicing the fewest number of connections.
Figure 30 WSA Upstream Proxy Group
Next, a routing rule needs to be defined to indicate when and how to direct transactions to the upstream proxy group. Use the Global Routing Policy if all traffic is to be handled by the upstream proxies. If no proxies are present, then leave the routing destination of the Global Routing Policy configured as Direct Connection. Figure 31 presents an example where all traffic is directed to the proxies in the Upstream-Lab_proxy group.
Figure 31 WSA Routing Policies
Web Access Policies
The access policies define how the Web Proxy handles HTTP requests and decrypted HTTPS connections for network users. By configuring access policies the school can control what Internet applications (instant messaging clients, peer-to-peer file-sharing, web browsers, Internet phone services, etc.) and URL categories students, staff and faculty may access. In addition, access policies can be used to block file downloads based on file characteristics, such as file size and file type.
The WSA comes with a default Global Policy that applies to all users. However, multiple policies can be defined when different policies need to be applied to different group of users. Figure 32 shows the global policy.
Figure 32 Global Access Policy
URL categories corresponding to content inappropriate for minors should be blocked in compliance with the school's Internet access policies. Figure 33 provides an example on how the "Adult/Sexually Explicit" category is blocked.
Figure 33 URL Categories
Layer-4 Traffic Monitoring (L4TM)
L4TM can be implemented in the school environment to identify rogue traffic across all network ports and detect malware attempts to bypass port 80. Additionally, L4TM is capable of identifying internal clients with malware and that attempt to phone-home across non-standard ports and protocols.
Implementing L4TM requires the following:
Step 1 Configuring L4TM interfaces
Step 2 Configuring WSA L4TM global settings
Step 3 Configuring traffic monitoring
Configuring L4TM Interfaces
The wiring type depends on how traffic is directed to the WSA appliance. Network taps and SPAN can be either configured in simplex or duplex mode. If using a hub, only duplex mode can be used. The wiring type configuration is typically done during the initial setup as described earlier in this document. Figure 34 show the wiring options.
Figure 34 L4TM Wiring Type
Configuring WSA L4TM Global Settings
The ports to be monitored can be specified in the L4TM Global Settings. Options are:
•All ports—Monitors all 65535 TCP ports for rogue activity.
•All ports except proxy ports—Monitors all TCP ports except HTTP and HTTPS proxy ports.
Note The Cisco ASA in the Internet perimeter is configured to allow only permitted ports, so any connection attempts on rogue ports should be blocked by the firewall.
Figure 35 shows the options.
Figure 35 L4TM Global Settings
Configuring Traffic Monitoring
While a hub or a network tap could be used, using SPAN port mirroring provides the greatest flexibility. SPAN allows the monitoring of port traffic based on VLANs or source interfaces and it can easily be reconfigured.The following is a configuration example of SPAN to redirect traffic to the WSA:! Enables port mirroring on the switch ports connecting to the firewall inside interfacesmonitor session 10 source interface Gi4/4monitor session 10 source interface Gi5/3!! Sets the interface connecting to the WSA as the destinationmonitor session 10 destination interface Gi6/3
The SPAN configuration can be seen on the switch with the show monitor session command.
Activity monitored by the L4TM feature can be seen in the L4 Traffic Monitor page of the WSA web-based GUI. Figure 36 shows client activity with a website known to be the source of malware.
Figure 36 L4 Traffic Monitor
Appendix E—CISF Protected Ports
Catalyst Integrated Security Features (CISF) includes private VLANs, port security, DHCP snooping, IPSource Guard, secure Address Resolution Protocol (ARP) detection, and dynamic ARP inspection. These features protect the network against attacks such as man-in-the-middle, spoofing, and infrastructure denial-of-services (DoS) attacks.
•Port Security—Where the number of MAC addresses allowed on a switch port is monitored and the switch can respond to violations with management messages and changes in the port state.
•DHCP snooping—Where DHCP messages are inspected and filtered to ensure that DHCP server messages only come from a trusted interface.
•IP Source Guard—Where the IP traffic is restricted based upon DHCP or static IP address MAC bindings to ensure that a host does not attempt to use the IP address of a neighboring host.
•Dynamic ARP inspection—Where the all ARP packets from untrusted interfaces are inspected to ensure that they contain valid MAC address and IP address pairings, preventing ARP spoofing attacks.
•ARP rate limiting—Where an excessive rate of ARP request (which must be processed by network hosts CPUs) and the switch responds with access restriction if this rate is exceeded.
•Storm Control—Prevents traffic on a LAN from being disrupted by a broadcast, multicast, or unicast storm.
The following is a sample CISF port configuration:switchport port-security maximum 2switchport port-securityswitchport port-security aging time 2switchport port-security violation restrictswitchport port-security aging type inactivityip arp inspection limit rate 100ip dhcp snooping limit rate 100storm-control broadcast level 20.00 10.00storm-control multicast level 50.00 30.00
Appendix F—Cisco Security Services
The Cisco SAFE Security Architecture is complimented by Cisco's rich portfolio of security services designed to support the entire solution lifecycle. Security is integrated everywhere and with the help of a lifecycle services approach, enterprises can deploy, operate, and optimize network platforms that defend critical business processes against attack and disruption, protect privacy, and support policy and regulatory compliance controls. Figure 37 shows how the Cisco Lifecycle Security Services support the entire lifecycle.
Figure 37 Cisco Lifecycle Security Services
Strategy and Assessments
Cisco offers a comprehensive set of assessment services based on a structured IT governance, risk management, and compliance approach to information security. These services help the customer understand the needs and gaps, recommend remediation based on industry and international best practices, and help the customer to strategically plan the evolution of an information security program, including updates to security policy, processes, and technology.
Deployment and Migration
Cisco offers deployment services to support the customer in planning, designing, and implementing Cisco security products and solutions. In addition, Cisco has services to support the customer in evolving its security policy and process-based controls to make people and the security architecture more effective.
Cisco Remote Management services engineers become an extension of the customer's IT staff, proactively monitoring the security technology infrastructure and providing incident, problem, change, configuration, and release management as well as management reporting 24 hours a day, 365 days a year.
The Cisco Security Intelligence services provide early warning intelligence, analysis, and proven mitigation techniques to help security professionals respond to the latest threats. The customer's IT staff can use the latest threat alerts, vulnerability analysis, and applied mitigation techniques developed by Cisco experts who use in-depth knowledge and sophisticated tools to verify anomalies and develop techniques that help ensure timely, accurate, and quick resolution to potential vulnerabilities and attacks.
The Cisco security Optimization service is an integrated service offering designed to assess, develop, and optimize the customer's security infrastructure on an ongoing basis. Through quarterly site visits and continual analysis and tuning, the Cisco security team becomes an extension of the customer's security staff, supporting them in long-term business security and risk management, as well as near-term tactical solutions to evolving security threats.